iContact vs Mailigen: The Best Email Marketing Tool for You

Navigate the email marketing landscape with confidence! Our guide compares iContact vs Mailigen to help you select the best tool for your business success.

Hey there, fellow digital marketer! Are you in a dilemma about choosing the right email marketing tool between iContact and Mailigen? Well, you’re in luck because today we’re diving deep into these two giants to help you make an informed decision. Let’s cut to the chase and start unraveling the layers, one feature at a time!

G2 Score – 4.1 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – Nil
TrustRadius Score -7.7 out of 10TrustRadius Score – 7.1 out of 10

Understanding User Interface and Ease of Use

In the world of email marketing, the user interface (UI) and ease of use are more than just fancy terms – they are the backbone of your day-to-day interactions with the tool. Let’s explore how iContact and Mailigen fare in this crucial aspect.

iContact: Simplicity Meets Efficiency

iContact is known for its straightforward and user-friendly interface. When you log in, you’re greeted with a dashboard that’s clean, uncluttered, and easy on the eyes. This is perfect for beginners and those who prefer a no-fuss approach to their email campaigns.

One of the highlights of iContact’s UI is its intuitive navigation. The menu is logically organized, making it a breeze to find what you’re looking for. Whether it’s creating a new email, accessing your contact lists, or analyzing campaign performance, everything is just a few clicks away.

For many, the thought of designing an email from scratch is daunting. iContact understands this and offers a robust library of templates. These templates are not only aesthetically pleasing but also cater to a variety of themes and industries. The best part? They are customizable, allowing you to add your personal touch without needing any design skills.

iContact doesn’t leave you in the dark. Their support system is commendable, with a wealth of learning resources at your disposal. From detailed FAQs to video tutorials, they ensure you have all the help you need to navigate through their platform efficiently.

Mailigen: Where Sophistication Meets Flexibility

Mailigen steps up the game with a slightly more sophisticated interface. It’s ideal for those who have been around the block and are looking for advanced features.

Mailigen’s dashboard offers a comprehensive overview of your campaigns. It’s like the control room of your email marketing efforts, providing you with real-time data and insights. This level of detail is invaluable for marketers who rely heavily on data-driven decisions.

If customization is your thing, Mailigen won’t disappoint. It offers a higher degree of flexibility in email design compared to iContact. This is particularly beneficial for brands that have specific design requirements or those who want to stand out with unique email layouts.

While Mailigen’s learning curve might be steeper, their tutorial and support system are top-notch. They offer in-depth guides and live support to help you master their platform. This is particularly helpful for marketers who are willing to invest a bit more time to leverage advanced features.

Choosing the right email marketing tool is crucial for your marketing strategy, and the user interface plays a significant role in that decision. iContact offers simplicity and ease, making it a great choice for beginners or those who prefer a straightforward approach. On the other hand, Mailigen caters to those looking for a more sophisticated and customizable experience.

Comparing Email Automation Capabilities

Email automation is the secret sauce to efficient and effective email marketing. It’s not just about sending emails; it’s about sending the right emails at the right time, without manually keeping tabs on every single contact. Let’s see how iContact and Mailigen stack up in this domain.

iContact: Automation for Everyone

iContact’s approach to automation is rooted in accessibility. Their platform is designed to make automation easy for everyone, regardless of technical expertise.

Creating an automation flow with iContact is almost as easy as sending a regular email. You can set up triggers based on subscriber actions, like opening an email or clicking a link. This allows you to send follow-up emails or specific content based on their behavior, enhancing engagement.

iContact shines in its ability to personalize emails without making it complicated. You can easily segment your contacts and tailor your messages based on their interests, past interactions, or demographics. This level of personalization, combined with automation, can significantly boost your campaign’s effectiveness.

Understanding how your automated campaigns perform is crucial, and iContact provides detailed reports for this. You can track open rates, click-through rates, and more, giving you insights into what’s working and what needs tweaking.

Mailigen: Advanced Automation for the Tech-Savvy

Mailigen takes a more advanced approach to automation, offering features that cater to the more tech-savvy user.

With Mailigen, you can create complex automation workflows. It goes beyond basic triggers, allowing you to set up multi-step sequences based on a series of actions or time intervals. This is particularly useful for comprehensive nurturing campaigns or detailed subscriber journeys.

Mailigen’s segmentation capabilities are robust. You can segment your lists based not just on subscriber data, but also on their behavior over time. This means you can create highly targeted campaigns that resonate with your audience at different stages of their journey with your brand.

A unique feature of Mailigen is the ability to incorporate A/B testing directly into your automation workflows. You can test different subject lines, content, or sending times within the same campaign, optimizing your strategy based on real-time data.

In the realm of email automation, both iContact and Mailigen offer compelling features, but cater to different user needs. iContact is ideal for those who want simplicity and efficiency in their automation, making it accessible even to novices. Mailigen, on the other hand, is a powerhouse for marketers who want to dive deep into sophisticated automation strategies and have the technical know-how to leverage its advanced features.

Exploring Integration and Compatibility

In today’s digital marketing landscape, your email marketing tool needs to play well with others. Integration and compatibility with other platforms and services are key to a seamless workflow. Let’s compare how iContact and Mailigen fare in this vital aspect.

iContact: Seamless Integration with Popular Platforms

iContact understands the importance of being part of a larger ecosystem and offers integration with a variety of popular platforms.

The strength of iContact lies in its ability to integrate with a wide array of services including CRM systems, social media platforms, and eCommerce solutions. This means you can easily connect your email marketing efforts with other aspects of your digital strategy, creating a cohesive experience.

For businesses that rely heavily on CRM systems, iContact’s seamless syncing capability is a boon. You can integrate with major CRM platforms, ensuring that your contact data is always up-to-date and consistent across all tools. This integration is particularly useful for maintaining a unified view of your customer interactions.

If you’re in the eCommerce space, iContact’s integration with shopping cart software can be a game-changer. It allows you to track customer behavior on your site and tailor your email campaigns accordingly. This kind of targeted approach can significantly boost your conversion rates.

Mailigen: Advanced Integration for Tech-Enabled Marketers

Mailigen steps up the game by offering more advanced integration options, catering to a tech-savvy audience.

Where Mailigen stands out is in its robust API, which allows for custom integrations. This is ideal for businesses with specific needs or those who use custom-built platforms. With API access, you can tailor the integration to fit your unique workflow.

Mailigen also excels in its ability to integrate with analytics tools. This is crucial for marketers who rely on data to inform their strategies. By connecting your email campaigns with your analytics platform, you can gain deeper insights into campaign performance and user behavior.

For those who use other automation tools, Mailigen’s integration capabilities ensure that your email marketing efforts are in sync with your broader automation strategy. This is particularly useful for businesses with complex marketing processes, as it helps streamline operations and reduce manual effort.

Integration and compatibility are crucial for an efficient and effective email marketing strategy. iContact offers a broad range of integrations with popular platforms, making it a great choice for businesses looking for ease and simplicity. On the other hand, Mailigen offers more advanced integration options, including API access for custom integration, making it suitable for tech-savvy marketers and businesses with specific integration needs.

Pricing Comparison

In the dynamic field of email marketing, choosing the right platform can significantly impact the success of your campaigns. iContact and Mailigen are two noteworthy contenders, offering a range of features tailored to meet the needs of diverse marketing strategies. While iContact is renowned for its user-friendly interface and efficient email marketing tools, Mailigen stands out with its integrated approach to email, SMS, and social media campaigns. This article delves into the pricing structures of iContact and Mailigen, providing a comprehensive comparison to aid marketers in making an informed decision based on their budgetary and functional requirements.

iContactBase Plan: Pricing starts at around $30/month for 500 subscribers and includes features like drag-and-drop editing, detailed tracking, and autoresponders.
Pro Plan: Starting at approximately $45/month for 500 subscribers, adding features like workflow automation, landing pages, and segmentation.
Custom pricing is available for higher volume needs and more advanced features.
MailigenPricing Structure: Based on the number of subscribers.
Basic Plans:
Up to 500 subscribers: Starts at approximately $10/month.
Up to 2,500 subscribers: Starts at approximately $25/month.
Up to 5,000 subscribers: Starts at approximately $40/month.
Higher Volume Plans:
Up to 10,000 subscribers: Pricing available upon request.
Up to 25,000 subscribers and more: Custom pricing.

iContact Pricing Overview

iContact is designed to support businesses of all sizes with its intuitive email marketing solutions. It emphasizes simplicity and effectiveness, catering especially to small and medium-sized businesses looking for reliable email marketing capabilities.

iContact employs a subscriber-based pricing model, where costs are determined by the size of your email list. This model is particularly straightforward, allowing for easy budgeting based on list growth. The platform offers various plans that scale in features and functionalities to accommodate different marketing needs, from basic email campaigns to more advanced strategies with comprehensive analytics and segmentation.

Starting with a basic plan that covers essential email marketing features, iContact provides options for businesses to upgrade as their needs evolve, including access to more sophisticated tools for automation, segmentation, and analytics. Custom pricing is also available for large or unique campaigns, ensuring that businesses of any size can tailor the service to their specific requirements.

Mailigen Pricing Overview

Mailigen prides itself on offering a multifaceted marketing platform that integrates email, SMS, and social media campaign tools. This approach is designed for businesses looking to execute comprehensive marketing strategies across multiple channels.

Like iContact, Mailigen’s pricing is largely based on the number of subscribers, but it also considers the inclusion of SMS and social media functionalities as part of its package. The platform offers several tiers, starting with basic email marketing features and extending to more advanced options that include automation, behavioral segmentation, and detailed analytics.

Mailigen’s pricing structure is designed to be flexible, accommodating businesses as they grow and their marketing strategies become more complex. The platform also offers pay-as-you-go options for SMS marketing, adding an additional layer of flexibility for businesses that value a multi-channel approach but have varying needs and campaign frequencies.

Comparative Insights

When evaluating iContact against Mailigen, several key considerations emerge:

  • Marketing Channel Focus: iContact specializes in email marketing, making it an ideal choice for businesses primarily focused on enhancing their email campaign strategies. Mailigen offers a broader range of marketing tools, including SMS and social media, which might be more appealing to businesses seeking an integrated multi-channel marketing approach.
  • Pricing Flexibility: Both platforms use a subscriber-based model, but Mailigen’s inclusion of SMS and the potential for more integrated campaigns can offer additional value for businesses looking for more than just email marketing solutions.
  • Feature Set and Scalability: iContact is known for its ease of use and efficiency, suitable for businesses looking for straightforward email marketing tools. Mailigen, with its comprehensive feature set across different channels, is better suited for businesses aiming to execute complex, integrated marketing campaigns.

The choice between iContact and Mailigen should be guided by your business’s specific marketing needs, budget, and preferred communication channels. iContact offers a solid, user-friendly platform for email marketing, ideal for those who prioritize simplicity and effectiveness in their email campaigns. On the other hand, Mailigen presents a compelling option for businesses looking to engage in multi-channel marketing, offering the flexibility to incorporate email, SMS, and social media into a cohesive marketing strategy. By carefully assessing your goals and the unique offerings of each platform, you can select the one that best aligns with your marketing objectives, ensuring a successful and efficient campaign execution.

WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Related: Check out our free SEO suite

Free SEO Suite by WinSavvy

Delving into Pricing and Value for Money

When it comes to choosing an email marketing tool, pricing and the value you get for your investment are pivotal factors. Let’s break down the pricing structures of iContact and Mailigen to see which offers the best value for your money.

iContact: Affordable and Transparent Pricing

iContact is known for its straightforward and budget-friendly pricing plans, making it an attractive option for small to medium-sized businesses.

iContact employs a tiered pricing structure based on the number of subscribers. This means you pay according to the size of your email list, which can be a cost-effective option for smaller lists. As your list grows, you can easily move up to a higher tier.

With iContact, even the most basic plan includes access to their core features like email templates, automation, and reporting. This inclusivity ensures that even smaller businesses can benefit from a full suite of email marketing tools without breaking the bank.

One of the commendable aspects of iContact’s pricing is the absence of hidden costs. You get what you pay for, and there are no surprises in terms of additional fees for essential features.

Mailigen: Value-Packed Plans for Advanced Users

Mailigen’s pricing structure is designed to cater to businesses looking for more advanced features and greater scalability.

Mailigen offers a variety of pricing options, including monthly and annual plans. Their pricing is also based on the number of subscribers but tends to be slightly higher than iContact, especially at higher tiers.

Even though Mailigen’s plans might be pricier, they pack a punch in terms of features. From advanced automation capabilities to sophisticated segmentation and A/B testing, even their lower-tier plans offer a range of advanced features.

For large businesses or those with specific needs, Mailigen offers custom plans. These plans are tailored to your specific requirements, ensuring that you only pay for what you need and get maximum value for your investment.

In terms of pricing and value for money, both iContact and Mailigen have their strengths. iContact is an excellent choice for those who need an affordable, no-frills solution that still covers all the basic email marketing needs. Mailigen, on the other hand, is more suitable for businesses willing to invest a bit more for advanced features and scalability. Your choice will depend on your budget and the complexity of your email marketing requirements.

Analyzing Customer Support and Service

The quality of customer support can be a deal-breaker when choosing an email marketing tool. It’s crucial to have reliable support for troubleshooting, guidance, and making the most out of the platform. Let’s compare the customer support services of iContact and Mailigen.

iContact: Dedicated and Accessible Support

iContact is renowned for its customer-centric approach to support, ensuring that users receive timely and effective assistance.

iContact offers support through various channels including email, phone, and live chat. This multi-channel approach ensures that you can get help in the way that’s most convenient for you.

Besides direct support, iContact provides an extensive knowledge base filled with articles, guides, and video tutorials. This resource is invaluable for self-help and can significantly reduce the need to reach out to customer service for common queries.

What sets iContact apart is the personalized attention it offers. Their customer support team is known for being responsive and attentive, ensuring that your specific issues and questions are addressed thoroughly.

Mailigen: Expert Support for Complex Queries

Mailigen takes pride in offering expert-level support, especially beneficial for users with complex needs or those utilizing advanced features of the platform.

Mailigen’s customer service team includes experts who are well-versed in technical aspects of email marketing. This is particularly useful if you’re dealing with complex integrations or need advice on advanced features.

Mailigen boasts an active user community and forums where you can share experiences, ask questions, and get advice from both peers and Mailigen experts. This community support can be a great resource for learning and problem-solving.

For users on custom plans, Mailigen offers tailored support to match the specific needs of their business. This can include dedicated account managers and specialized assistance, ensuring that large-scale or unique requirements are met effectively.

Customer support is an essential aspect of any email marketing tool. iContact excels with its multi-channel, responsive support and comprehensive knowledge base, making it ideal for those who value accessibility and personalized assistance. Mailigen, on the other hand, offers more specialized and technical support, along with an active community for peer-to-peer interaction, catering to users with more complex needs or those seeking in-depth guidance.

Examining Email Deliverability and Reliability

Email deliverability is a critical factor in the success of your email marketing campaigns. It’s not just about sending emails; it’s about ensuring they reach the inbox and not the spam folder. Let’s delve into how iContact and Mailigen handle email deliverability and reliability.

iContact: Strong Focus on Deliverability

iContact places a high emphasis on ensuring that your emails reach their intended destination effectively.

iContact has invested in a robust infrastructure that maximizes email deliverability. This includes using reputable IP addresses and maintaining good relationships with Internet Service Providers (ISPs), which are crucial for avoiding spam filters.

With iContact, users generally report high deliverability rates. This is attributed to their stringent practices in email list management and regular updates to their sending methods in response to changing email algorithms.

iContact provides tools to help you manage your email lists proactively. These include features for cleaning your list of inactive subscribers and ensuring that your contacts are engaged, both of which are essential for maintaining a high deliverability rate.

Mailigen: Advanced Deliverability Features

Mailigen also takes email deliverability seriously, with advanced features designed to keep your emails landing in the right place.

Mailigen employs the latest technology to ensure emails are delivered efficiently. This includes sophisticated algorithms that monitor email sending patterns and adjust them to optimize deliverability.

Mailigen provides detailed analytics on your email campaigns, giving you insights into deliverability rates, open rates, and bounce rates. This data is crucial for identifying and rectifying issues that could affect your email performance.

Mailigen’s advanced personalization and segmentation capabilities can indirectly boost deliverability. By sending relevant and targeted emails, you increase the likelihood of engagement, which in turn positively impacts your sender reputation and deliverability.


In the ever-evolving world of email marketing, selecting the right tool can be the linchpin for your campaign’s success. Our journey through the key aspects of iContact and Mailigen has revealed distinct strengths in each, catering to diverse needs and preferences.

iContact emerges as a champion of simplicity and user-friendliness, making it an excellent choice for beginners and those who value straightforward, efficient email marketing solutions. Its budget-friendly pricing, combined with a strong focus on deliverability and responsive customer support, positions it as a reliable ally for small to medium-sized businesses.

Mailigen, on the other hand, steps into the spotlight with its advanced features and customization options. It caters to the more tech-savvy marketer, offering sophisticated automation, detailed analytics, and robust integration capabilities. Although it comes at a higher price point, the value it delivers is indisputable, particularly for businesses seeking depth and scalability in their email marketing endeavors.

Read More:

author avatar
Poulomi Chakraborty
Poulomi Chakraborty is at the heart of our digital marketing team at WinSavvy. With a keen grasp on the ever-evolving world of SEO and digital trends, she is known for her thoughtful and strategic approach. Poulomi blends deep industry knowledge with a genuine enthusiasm for helping businesses shine online. Her ability to translate complex digital concepts into clear, actionable strategies is what sets her apart.
Scroll to Top