Benchmark Email vs MoonMail: The Best Email Marketing Tool for 2024

In the competitive landscape of email marketing in 2024, choosing the right tool can be a game-changer for businesses of all sizes. Benchmark Email and MoonMail are both heavy hitters in this domain, but which one truly stands out as the best choice for your marketing needs this year? This comprehensive analysis will dive into the nitty-gritty of both platforms, comparing key features, usability, and overall performance to guide you in making an informed decision.

Benchmark EmailMoonMail
Benchmark Email Toolmoonmail
G2 Score – 4.3 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – 3.8 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score – 6.5 out of 10TrustRadius Score – nil

Ease of Use and User Interface: The Battle of Accessibility

A user-friendly interface and a smooth setup process are crucial for any email marketing tool. Let’s compare how Benchmark Email and MoonMail approach this.

Benchmark Email: Simplicity Meets Functionality

Benchmark Email has consistently been praised for its straightforward and intuitive interface. Right from the start, users are greeted with a clean and navigable dashboard, making the initial setup process hassle-free. This ease of entry is a significant advantage, especially for small businesses or solo entrepreneurs who might not have extensive technical expertise.

The platform’s design focuses on simplicity without compromising on functionality. Creating a new campaign, managing contact lists, or analyzing reports is intuitive, thanks to the logically organized layout and clear instructions. This user-centric design ensures that even those new to email marketing can quickly become proficient in using the tool.

MoonMail: A Modern Approach to Email Marketing

MoonMail takes a slightly different approach, blending a modern interface with a range of advanced features. The setup process is also streamlined, but it offers more customization options out of the gate. This approach is beneficial for users who have some experience in email marketing and prefer a tool that can be tailored to their specific needs right from the start.

The dashboard and overall design of MoonMail are sleek and contemporary, offering a visually pleasing user experience. The platform provides easy access to all vital features, making it convenient for users to navigate through various aspects of their email marketing campaigns.

Crafting Your Email Campaign

The core of any email marketing tool is its ability to create and send engaging emails. Let’s compare the email creation capabilities of Benchmark Email and MoonMail.

Benchmark Email: Empowering Creativity with Ease

Benchmark Email offers an excellent drag-and-drop email editor, allowing users to create visually appealing emails without needing advanced design skills. The platform provides a wide array of customizable templates that cater to various industries and occasions, making it easy to create professional-looking emails.

The editor is not only about aesthetics; it also includes functionality for adding elements like social media buttons, videos, and interactive content. This blend of ease of use and creative freedom makes Benchmark Email a strong contender for businesses looking to create impactful email campaigns efficiently.

MoonMail: Flexibility for the Innovative Marketer

MoonMail steps up in terms of flexibility and customization in email design. It provides a range of templates, but with a greater emphasis on customization and advanced design features. This is particularly advantageous for brands that have specific design requirements or those looking to stand out with unique email aesthetics.

MoonMail’s design capabilities cater to users who want more control over their email layouts and branding elements, offering a platform for innovative and bespoke email designs.

Bottom Line

In terms of ease of use and user interface, both Benchmark Email and MoonMail offer compelling experiences but cater to different user preferences. Benchmark Email is ideal for those who value straightforward, user-friendly interfaces, while MoonMail appeals to users who prefer a modern, customizable experience right from the start.

Email Automation: Streamlining Communication

Email automation is a critical feature in today’s email marketing tools, allowing businesses to send timely and personalized messages automatically. Let’s examine how Benchmark Email and MoonMail approach automation.

Benchmark Email: Making Automation Accessible

Benchmark Email has established itself as a platform that makes email automation accessible to all levels of users. It offers a straightforward way to create automated email sequences like welcome emails, birthday wishes, or follow-up messages. This feature is particularly beneficial for businesses looking to engage with their audience without constant manual input.

The strength of Benchmark Email’s automation lies in its simplicity and effectiveness. The platform offers a visual automation journey builder, enabling users to easily set up triggers and actions for their automated emails. This user-friendly approach ensures that even those with limited technical skills can implement sophisticated automated campaigns.

MoonMail: Advanced Automation for Targeted Campaigns

MoonMail steps up the game with more advanced automation features. It allows for complex automated email sequences based on specific user actions or behaviors. This level of customization is ideal for businesses that need detailed and targeted email campaigns.

MoonMail’s automation capabilities are designed for users who require a high degree of control over their email marketing strategy. With options to segment audiences and personalize messages based on user data, MoonMail enables businesses to create highly relevant and engaging automated emails.

Integrating Automation with Overall Marketing Strategy

Both Benchmark Email and MoonMail recognize the importance of integrating email automation with the broader marketing strategy.

Benchmark Email: Seamless Integration with E-commerce and Other Tools

Benchmark Email offers robust integration capabilities, especially with e-commerce platforms. This allows businesses to automate emails based on customer purchase behavior or other e-commerce triggers, creating a cohesive marketing approach that extends beyond email.

MoonMail: Versatile Integrations for a Unified Approach

MoonMail provides a wide range of integration options, ensuring its email automation works in tandem with other business tools. Its advanced automation features can be synchronized with CRM systems, analytics tools, and more, offering a unified marketing strategy.

Bottom Line

In the realm of email automation, Benchmark Email and MoonMail cater to different needs. Benchmark Email is ideal for those seeking easy-to-use automation to enhance customer engagement effectively. MoonMail, on the other hand, offers more advanced automation capabilities, suitable for businesses aiming for a high level of customization and targeting in their email campaigns.

Analytics and Reporting: Measuring Campaign Effectiveness

Understanding and analyzing the performance of email campaigns is crucial for any marketing strategy. Let’s delve into how Benchmark Email and MoonMail provide analytics and reporting features.

Benchmark Email: User-Friendly Analytics for Informed Decisions

Benchmark Email offers a comprehensive analytics suite that is both informative and easy to understand. When you send out a campaign, you get access to essential metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and bounce rates. These metrics are presented in a straightforward, visually appealing format, making it easy for users to gauge the success of their campaigns.

A key strength of Benchmark Email’s analytics is its focus on actionable insights. Features like link tracking and heat maps provide a deeper understanding of subscriber engagement, helping you refine your content and design for future campaigns. Additionally, the platform offers social media tracking, allowing you to see the broader impact of your emails in terms of shares and overall engagement.

MoonMail: Advanced Analytics for Data-Driven Marketers

MoonMail takes analytics a step further by offering a more detailed and comprehensive suite of reporting tools. The platform caters to data-driven marketers who seek in-depth insights into their campaigns. With MoonMail, you can track individual user behaviors, segment your reports based on various criteria, and gain a deep understanding of how different elements of your emails affect overall performance.

One of the standout features of MoonMail’s analytics is the ability to track the customer journey across multiple touchpoints. This provides a holistic view of how your email campaigns integrate with other marketing efforts, helping you create a more unified and effective marketing strategy.

Leveraging Data for Strategic Advantage

Both Benchmark Email and MoonMail understand the importance of not just providing data, but helping users leverage this data for strategic advantage.

Benchmark Email: Simplified Data Interpretation

Benchmark Email’s approach to analytics is geared towards making data interpretation as simple as possible. The platform provides the essential data in an easily digestible format, accompanied by tips and suggestions for improvement, making it ideal for businesses that need quick insights to inform their decisions.

MoonMail: In-Depth Data Analysis

MoonMail’s analytics are designed for a more in-depth analysis, providing comprehensive data that can inform complex marketing strategies. This is particularly beneficial for businesses that base their decisions on detailed data analysis and require extensive reporting capabilities.

Bottom Line

In terms of analytics and reporting, Benchmark Email is well-suited for businesses that need straightforward, accessible insights for effective campaign management. In contrast, MoonMail, with its advanced analytics and comprehensive reporting capabilities, is better suited for businesses that require detailed, data-driven insights into their email marketing performance.

WinSavvy helps VC-Funded Startups scale their digital marketing with a focus on SEO and social media retargeting.
Click here to learn more!

Pricing and Affordability: Evaluating Cost-Effectiveness

In the quest for the best email marketing tool, pricing is a decisive factor, especially for small businesses or startups mindful of their budget. Let’s assess how Benchmark Email and MoonMail stack up in terms of pricing and the value they offer.

Benchmark EmailFree Plan: Offers basic email marketing features with a subscriber limit and Benchmark branding.
Pro Plan: Pricing starts at $13/month for 500 subscribers and includes advanced features like automation, A/B testing, and targeted emailing. The price increases based on the number of subscribers.
MoonmailFree Plan: Includes limited features for up to 2,000 subscribers and 300 emails per day.
Starter Plan: Typically starts around $23.99/month for up to 10,000 subscribers.
Growing Business Plan: For larger lists, priced around $79/month for up to 50,000 subscribers.
Enterprise solutions: Custom pricing based on the business’s specific requirements.

Benchmark Email: Budget-Friendly with Flexible Plans

Benchmark Email is recognized for its budget-friendly pricing structure, which appeals particularly to small and medium-sized businesses. The platform offers a free version with basic features, an excellent starting point for those new to email marketing or with limited needs.

As businesses grow, Benchmark Email provides various tiered plans based on the number of subscribers and desired features. This scalable pricing model allows users to select a plan that matches their specific needs and budget, ensuring they only pay for what they use. The higher-tier plans include more advanced features like automation and detailed analytics, still maintaining competitive pricing.

MoonMail: Diverse Pricing for Varied Needs

MoonMail presents a different approach to pricing. Instead of a free tier, it offers a range of paid plans that cater to different levels of email marketing needs, from basic to advanced. The pricing is based on factors like the number of emails sent and the level of customization and automation required.

While MoonMail might be a bit pricier compared to Benchmark Email, especially for its higher-tier plans, it justifies the cost with its advanced features and capabilities. For businesses that require extensive email marketing tools and have the budget for it, MoonMail can be a valuable investment.

Assessing the ROI

When considering the pricing, it’s essential to evaluate the potential return on investment (ROI) that each platform can offer.

Benchmark Email: Cost-Effectiveness for Growing Businesses

Benchmark Email’s affordability makes it an attractive option for growing businesses and startups. Its ease of use, combined with essential features, provides a solid foundation for effective email marketing without a significant investment.

MoonMail: Higher Investment for Advanced Features

MoonMail’s pricing reflects its advanced capabilities. For businesses that need sophisticated email marketing solutions and are willing to invest more, MoonMail offers substantial value through its comprehensive feature set and customization options.

Bottom Line

Choosing between Benchmark Email and MoonMail in terms of pricing and value depends largely on your specific business requirements and budget. Benchmark Email is an excellent choice for those looking for an affordable, scalable solution with all the necessary features for effective email marketing. On the other hand, MoonMail caters to businesses that need more advanced features and are willing to invest in a more comprehensive email marketing platform.

Integration Capabilities: Expanding the Functionality of Email Marketing

The ability to integrate seamlessly with other business tools and platforms is a key feature of any modern email marketing tool. Let’s compare how Benchmark Email and MoonMail handle integrations.

Benchmark Email: Wide-Ranging Integrations for Enhanced Functionality

Benchmark Email offers a broad spectrum of integration options with various platforms and services. This includes popular CRM systems, e-commerce platforms, social media tools, and more. These integrations are vital for businesses looking to streamline their marketing efforts and maintain consistency across different channels.

The process of setting up these integrations in Benchmark Email is designed to be user-friendly. The platform aims to make it easy for users to connect their email marketing efforts with other aspects of their business, enhancing overall efficiency. For instance, integrating an e-commerce platform allows for automated email triggers based on customer behavior, such as purchases or cart abandonment.

MoonMail: Advanced Integration for a Unified Marketing Strategy

MoonMail takes a slightly more advanced approach to integration. It offers deep integration capabilities with a range of tools, including advanced CRM systems, e-commerce solutions, and analytics platforms. These integrations allow for a more comprehensive and data-driven email marketing strategy.

MoonMail’s focus is on providing a seamless flow of data between different systems. This is particularly beneficial for businesses that rely on detailed data analytics to tailor their marketing strategies. The ability to integrate complex systems means that MoonMail can fit into a broader, more intricate marketing tech stack.

The Role of APIs in Custom Integration

Both Benchmark Email and MoonMail offer API access, enabling further customization and integration capabilities.

Benchmark Email: Flexible API for Custom Needs

Benchmark Email’s API is designed for flexibility, allowing businesses to create custom integrations that suit their specific requirements. This is particularly useful for businesses with unique workflows or those that use niche tools not covered by standard integrations.

MoonMail: Robust API for Complex Integrations

MoonMail offers a more robust API, catering to businesses that need complex, tailor-made integrations. While it might require more technical expertise, the level of customization and integration depth it offers can be a significant advantage for larger businesses or those with specific needs.

Bottom Line

When it comes to integration capabilities, both Benchmark Email and MoonMail offer effective solutions, but with different focuses. Benchmark Email is ideal for businesses seeking a wide range of straightforward integrations to enhance their marketing efforts. MoonMail, on the other hand, caters to those who need deeper, more sophisticated integrations, providing a comprehensive solution for integrating email marketing into a complex business ecosystem.

Customer Support and Learning Resources: Ensuring a Smooth Marketing Journey

In the realm of email marketing, having access to reliable customer support and comprehensive learning resources can significantly enhance the user experience. Let’s examine how Benchmark Email and MoonMail fare in these crucial areas.

Benchmark Email: Committed to User Support and Education

Benchmark Email has a strong reputation for providing excellent customer support. Users have access to a range of support options including email, live chat, and phone support. Known for its responsiveness and helpfulness, Benchmark’s support team plays a pivotal role in assisting users with various queries and challenges.

In addition to direct support, Benchmark Email offers an extensive library of educational resources. This includes detailed guides, how-to articles, video tutorials, and webinars. These resources cover a wide spectrum of topics, from basic email marketing techniques to advanced strategies, making them invaluable for marketers at all levels.

Benchmark Email also keeps its users up to date with the latest trends and best practices in email marketing through regular blog posts and newsletters.

MoonMail: Providing In-depth Support and Advanced Learning

MoonMail also places a high emphasis on customer support. It offers multiple channels for support, including email and live chat, with a focus on providing detailed and technical assistance. MoonMail’s support team is particularly noted for their expertise in handling more complex queries related to the platform’s advanced features.

Alongside customer support, MoonMail provides a wealth of learning materials. Their resources include comprehensive guides, in-depth case studies, and instructional videos. These materials are especially beneficial for users looking to delve deeper into the nuances of email marketing and utilize MoonMail’s advanced features to their fullest.

MoonMail also conducts webinars and interactive sessions, offering users opportunities to learn directly from experts and stay abreast of evolving marketing trends.

User Empowerment through Support and Education

Both Benchmark Email and MoonMail understand the importance of not just offering tools, but also empowering users to effectively utilize these tools.

Benchmark Email: Making Email Marketing Accessible

Benchmark Email’s approach to support and education is geared towards making email marketing accessible and manageable for everyone. The platform ensures that users have the support and resources they need to navigate their email marketing journey successfully, regardless of their prior experience.

MoonMail: Catering to the Advanced User

MoonMail’s focus on in-depth support and advanced learning resources caters to users who require a deeper understanding of email marketing and wish to leverage MoonMail’s sophisticated features effectively.

Bottom Line

In terms of customer support and educational resources, both Benchmark Email and MoonMail excel, each addressing different user needs. Benchmark Email is ideal for those seeking comprehensive support and resources that make email marketing straightforward and effective. MoonMail, with its detailed support and advanced learning materials, is better suited for users who seek in-depth knowledge and expertise in advanced email marketing tactics.


In the showdown between Benchmark Email and MoonMail for the title of the best email marketing tool for 2024, the choice largely depends on your specific needs and expertise level. Benchmark Email shines with its user-friendly interface, affordable pricing, and excellent customer support, making it an ideal choice for small to medium-sized businesses or those new to email marketing. Its straightforward approach ensures ease of use, making it accessible for users at all skill levels.

MoonMail, on the other hand, appeals to businesses looking for advanced email marketing features and deeper integration capabilities. With its sophisticated automation tools, in-depth analytics, and robust API for complex integrations, MoonMail caters to more experienced marketers or larger businesses that require a high degree of customization and control over their email campaigns. Ultimately, whether you opt for the simplicity and user-friendliness of Benchmark Email or the advanced features and flexibility of MoonMail, both platforms offer powerful tools to enhance your email marketing strategy in 2024.

Read Next:

Scroll to Top