Benchmark Email vs VerticalResponse: The Best Email Marketing Tool for 2024

Optimize your email marketing game in 2024! Benchmark Email vs VerticalResponse - Discover the best tool for your campaigns with our in-depth comparison. Explore today.

As we step into 2024, the competition in the world of email marketing tools is more intense than ever. Among the top contenders vying for your attention are Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse. Both tools promise to revolutionize how businesses communicate with their audiences, but which one truly stands out as the best for this year? Let’s delve into a detailed comparison to help you make an informed decision.

Benchmark EmailVerticalResponse
Benchmark Email Toolvertical response
G2 Score – 4.3 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – 3.3 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score – 6.5 out of 10TrustRadius Score – 10.0 out of 10

User Experience: Navigating with Ease

In the realm of email marketing, a tool’s usability can make or break its effectiveness. Let’s start by comparing how Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse fare in terms of user experience, particularly focusing on their initial setup and learning curve.

Benchmark Email: The Straightforward Starter

Benchmark Email is renowned for its user-friendly interface. From the moment you sign up, you’re greeted with a clean, intuitive dashboard that feels welcoming, especially for beginners. The setup process is streamlined; within a few clicks, you can start creating your first campaign. This ease of entry is a big plus for small businesses or solo entrepreneurs who don’t want to spend hours figuring out a complex system.

The platform offers a smooth learning curve. With its straightforward drag-and-drop email builder, crafting professional-looking emails becomes a hassle-free experience. Benchmark provides a variety of customizable templates, making it easy for anyone to create emails that resonate with their brand, regardless of their design skills.

VerticalResponse: The Intuitive Innovator

VerticalResponse, on the other hand, also places a high value on user experience but takes a slightly different approach. The platform prides itself on its simplicity coupled with powerful features. Setting up an account is just as easy as with Benchmark Email, but where VerticalResponse shines is in its innovative approach to campaign creation.

One of the unique aspects of VerticalResponse is its intuitive guidance system. As you build your email, the tool offers helpful tips and suggestions, almost like having a virtual assistant by your side. This feature is particularly useful for those who are new to email marketing and can benefit from real-time guidance.

Designing Emails: A Creative Journey

Creating an email that stands out in your subscribers’ inboxes is crucial. Let’s see how both platforms cater to the creative aspect of email design.

Benchmark Email: Creativity Made Simple

Benchmark Email’s design capabilities are centered around simplicity without sacrificing creativity. The drag-and-drop builder, combined with a wide array of templates, provides a solid foundation for creating eye-catching emails. You can easily add images, videos, and custom HTML elements to your emails, giving you the freedom to be as creative as you want.

The beauty of Benchmark’s design process is in its balance between simplicity and flexibility. It offers enough customization options to make your emails unique, but not so many that you feel overwhelmed.

VerticalResponse: Empowering Design Freedom

VerticalResponse steps up the game in email design with its advanced customization options. While it maintains an easy-to-use interface, it offers more depth in terms of design flexibility. You have the freedom to tweak almost every aspect of your email, from fonts and colors to layout structures.

For those who have a keen eye for design or specific branding requirements, VerticalResponse provides the tools to bring your vision to life. The platform also includes responsive design features, ensuring your emails look great on any device, which is critical in today’s mobile-centric world.

Bottom Line

Both Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse offer excellent user experiences, but they cater to slightly different preferences. Benchmark Email is ideal for those who value simplicity and speed in setting up campaigns. In contrast, VerticalResponse appeals to users who seek a balance between easy navigation and more comprehensive design capabilities.

Email Automation: Streamlining Your Marketing Efforts

In the realm of email marketing, the power of automation cannot be overstated. It’s all about sending the right message to the right person at the right time, without manual intervention. Let’s delve into how Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse handle email automation.

Benchmark Email: Automation for Everyone

Benchmark Email has positioned itself as a tool that democratizes email automation. Whether you’re a small business owner or a marketing manager in a larger company, Benchmark’s automation features are designed to be accessible and effective. The platform offers a variety of automation templates that cater to common marketing scenarios like welcome series, follow-up sequences, and re-engagement campaigns.

What makes Benchmark’s automation stand out is its user-friendly nature. The process of setting up automated emails is intuitive, thanks to a visual workflow designer. You can easily create triggers based on subscriber actions, like opening an email or clicking a specific link, and then set up corresponding automated responses. This level of automation is potent for keeping your audience engaged without constant manual effort.

VerticalResponse: Advanced Automation with a Personal Touch

VerticalResponse takes a slightly more sophisticated approach to automation. The platform offers all the standard automation capabilities you’d expect, like autoresponders and trigger-based emails, but adds a layer of personalization that sets it apart.

One of the key features of VerticalResponse’s automation is its ability to segment and target emails based on detailed subscriber data. This means you can send highly personalized emails based on factors like past purchases, geographic location, and engagement history. Such targeted automation can significantly increase the relevance and effectiveness of your campaigns.

VerticalResponse also offers more advanced automation options, such as A/B testing within automated sequences, which allows you to continuously optimize your emails for better performance.

Integrating Automation with Other Marketing Efforts

Both platforms understand that email automation doesn’t exist in a vacuum but is part of a broader marketing strategy.

Benchmark Email: Seamless Integration

Benchmark Email ensures that its automation features integrate seamlessly with other tools and platforms. For example, if you run an e-commerce store on Shopify or WooCommerce, you can link it with Benchmark to automate emails based on purchase behavior or cart abandonment. This integration extends the power of automation beyond just email, creating a cohesive marketing experience.

VerticalResponse: A Holistic Approach

Similarly, VerticalResponse allows for integrations with a variety of CRM and e-commerce platforms. This holistic approach means that your automated emails can be informed by a wide range of data points, leading to more sophisticated and effective marketing strategies.

Bottom Line

In choosing between Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse for automation, it boils down to your specific needs. Benchmark Email is fantastic for those who want a straightforward, easy-to-use automation system that covers all the basics. VerticalResponse, however, is more suitable for businesses that are looking for advanced automation features with a strong focus on personalization and integration with broader marketing efforts.

WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Related: Check out our free SEO suite

Free SEO Suite by WinSavvy

Analytics and Reporting: Measuring Success and Making Informed Decisions

The ability to track and understand the performance of your email campaigns is crucial in refining your strategy and achieving better results. Let’s compare how Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse handle analytics and reporting.

Benchmark Email: Insights for Impact

Benchmark Email offers a comprehensive suite of analytics and reporting tools designed to be easy to understand yet insightful. When you send out a campaign, you can track key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and bounce rates. This data is presented in a user-friendly dashboard, allowing you to quickly gauge the success of your campaigns.

But Benchmark Email goes beyond just basic metrics. It also provides heat maps to show where recipients are clicking within your emails, helping you understand what content catches their attention. Additionally, you can track how your emails perform on different devices, which is crucial in optimizing for mobile users.

The platform also offers social media tracking, enabling you to measure the impact of your emails in terms of social shares and engagement. This holistic view of your campaign performance can guide your future marketing strategies.

VerticalResponse: Deep Dive into Data

VerticalResponse takes a more detailed approach to analytics and reporting. It offers all the standard metrics you’d expect, but with added layers of depth. For instance, you can segment your reports based on different subscriber demographics or behaviors, giving you a more granular view of your campaign performance.

One of the standout features of VerticalResponse’s analytics is its ability to track subscriber journey. You can see not just how many people opened an email, but also follow their path through your website after clicking a link. This level of detail is invaluable for understanding how your emails translate into actual business outcomes, like sales or inquiries.

Moreover, VerticalResponse integrates these analytics with A/B testing results, providing insights into what email variations perform best and why. This data-driven approach can significantly enhance the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts.

Making Sense of the Metrics

Both platforms recognize the importance of not just collecting data, but also making it actionable.

Benchmark Email: Actionable Analytics for Everyone

Benchmark Email’s analytics are designed to be accessible. Even if you’re not a data expert, you can understand and act on the insights provided. The platform also offers guidance on how to improve your metrics, making it a learning tool as well as a reporting one.

VerticalResponse: Data-Driven Decisions

VerticalResponse’s detailed analytics are ideal for those who love diving into data and extracting every bit of insight. The platform empowers you to make data-driven decisions to refine your campaigns continuously.

Bottom Line

In the realm of analytics and reporting, your choice between Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse will depend on your preference for simplicity versus depth. Benchmark Email offers straightforward, easy-to-understand insights perfect for small businesses or those new to email marketing. VerticalResponse, with its detailed analytics and advanced reporting capabilities, is better suited for businesses that need a deeper understanding of their email campaign performance.

Pricing and Affordability: Balancing Cost and Features

In the competitive landscape of email marketing tools, pricing is a critical factor, particularly for small businesses and startups operating on tight budgets. Let’s examine how Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse stack up in terms of pricing and what they offer for their cost.

Benchmark EmailFree Plan: Offers basic email marketing features with a subscriber limit and Benchmark branding.
Pro Plan: Pricing starts at $13/month for 500 subscribers and includes advanced features like automation, A/B testing, and targeted emailing. The price increases based on the number of subscribers.
VerticalResponseFree Plan: Offers up to 300 emails per month to up to 300 contacts.
Basic Plan: Starting around $11/month for up to 500 contacts, offering unlimited emails and more tools.
Pro Plan: Starting from around $16/month for up to 500 contacts, adding advanced features like automated follow-up emails, landing pages, and email scheduling.
Pro+ Plan: Offers full-service email marketing starting around $196 per month, where a team of experts designs and sends your emails for you.

Benchmark Email: Cost-Effective Solutions for Various Needs

Benchmark Email is known for its cost-effective pricing plans, making it an attractive option for businesses looking for quality services without breaking the bank. The platform offers a free plan, which is quite generous in terms of the features it includes, like basic email automation and access to most of their design templates. This plan is ideal for small businesses or individuals just starting with email marketing.

As your needs grow, Benchmark Email’s paid plans offer increased capabilities at reasonable prices. The plans are tiered based on the number of subscribers, and each tier unlocks additional features. Businesses can choose a plan that aligns with their size and requirements, ensuring they only pay for what they need.

The transparency and flexibility in Benchmark Email’s pricing structure are commendable. There are no hidden fees, and scaling up or down as per your business needs is straightforward.

VerticalResponse: Premium Services at a Premium Price

VerticalResponse, on the other hand, positions itself as a premium email marketing solution. While it doesn’t offer a free tier, its pricing reflects the advanced features and capabilities it brings to the table, such as detailed analytics, advanced automation, and extensive customization options.

The pricing structure of VerticalResponse is based on the number of contacts and the level of features you need. For businesses that require a comprehensive suite of tools and have the budget for it, VerticalResponse offers great value. The investment can be justified by the extensive capabilities and the potential return on investment in terms of successful email marketing campaigns.

VerticalResponse is a great fit for medium to larger businesses or those who prioritize having a wide range of features and detailed analytics over pricing.

Deciding Based on Business Size and Needs

When it comes to choosing between Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse based on pricing, it largely depends on the size of your business and your specific needs.

Benchmark Email: Ideal for Budget-Conscious Businesses

For startups, small businesses, or those on a tight budget, Benchmark Email is a fantastic choice. It offers all the essential features of an email marketing tool at a very affordable price.

VerticalResponse: Catering to Businesses with Bigger Budgets

For larger businesses or those requiring a more sophisticated range of tools and are willing to invest more, VerticalResponse is the way to go. Its advanced features and comprehensive capabilities can significantly enhance your email marketing efforts.

Bottom Line

In summary, Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse cater to different segments of the market when it comes to pricing. Benchmark Email is more budget-friendly and offers great value for money, making it suitable for smaller businesses or those just starting with email marketing. VerticalResponse, with its premium pricing, caters to businesses that need a comprehensive, feature-rich email marketing solution and are willing to make a higher investment.

Customer Support and Resources: Ensuring a Smooth Email Marketing Journey

Effective customer support and comprehensive learning resources are crucial for any email marketing tool, especially for businesses that are new to this domain. Let’s evaluate how Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse support their users in this regard.

Benchmark Email: Dedicated Support and Extensive Resources

Benchmark Email is well-regarded for its customer support. They offer various channels for support, including email, live chat, and phone support, ensuring that users can get help in a way that suits them best. The response times are generally quick, and the support team is known for being knowledgeable and helpful.

In addition to direct support, Benchmark Email provides a wealth of resources for users. Their website features an extensive knowledge base, including articles, how-to guides, and video tutorials. These resources cover everything from basic email marketing concepts to advanced strategies, making them invaluable for both beginners and experienced marketers.

Benchmark Email also conducts webinars and training sessions, offering users an opportunity to learn from experts and stay updated on the latest trends and best practices in email marketing.

VerticalResponse: Comprehensive Support for a Seamless Experience

VerticalResponse also places a strong emphasis on customer support. They offer support through email, live chat, and phone, with a reputation for being responsive and efficient. The support team at VerticalResponse is praised for their expertise and willingness to go the extra mile to resolve user queries.

Similar to Benchmark Email, VerticalResponse provides a robust library of educational content. Their online resources are rich in informative articles, step-by-step guides, and tutorial videos. These materials are designed to help users at every step of their email marketing journey, from setting up their first campaign to optimizing their strategies for better results.

VerticalResponse also keeps its users informed and educated through regular webinars and newsletters, which cover a range of topics relevant to email marketing.

Empowering Users with Knowledge and Support

Both platforms understand the importance of not just providing a tool, but also ensuring that users can effectively utilize it.

Benchmark Email: A Focus on User Empowerment

Benchmark Email’s approach to support and resources is centered around user empowerment. By providing easy access to a wide range of learning materials and reliable support, they ensure that users can make the most out of their email marketing efforts.

VerticalResponse: Going Beyond Basic Support

VerticalResponse goes beyond basic support by offering in-depth resources that cater to both beginners and advanced users. Their commitment to customer education is evident in the quality and range of their resources.

Bottom Line

When it comes to customer support and resources, both Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse excel in providing their users with the necessary tools and knowledge. Benchmark Email is ideal for those who value a combination of responsive support and comprehensive educational materials. VerticalResponse, with its detailed resources and expert support team, is perfect for businesses that seek a deeper understanding of email marketing strategies and best practices.


In the quest for the best email marketing tool of 2024, Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse both present strong cases, each catering to different needs and preferences. Benchmark Email stands out with its user-friendly interface, affordability, and excellent customer support, making it a great choice for small businesses and beginners in email marketing. Its straightforward approach to automation, design, and analytics ensures that users can effectively manage their email campaigns without a steep learning curve.

On the other hand, VerticalResponse appeals to businesses looking for a more sophisticated set of features, especially in terms of automation, design customization, and in-depth analytics. Its comprehensive support and resources cater to users who seek a deeper understanding of email marketing strategies and are willing to invest in a premium service. Ultimately, the decision between Benchmark Email and VerticalResponse should align with your business’s specific needs, budget, and the level of complexity you require in your email marketing efforts. Both tools offer robust capabilities to enhance your email marketing strategy in 2024.

Read Next:

author avatar
Poulomi Chakraborty
Poulomi Chakraborty is at the heart of our digital marketing team at WinSavvy. With a keen grasp on the ever-evolving world of SEO and digital trends, she is known for her thoughtful and strategic approach. Poulomi blends deep industry knowledge with a genuine enthusiasm for helping businesses shine online. Her ability to translate complex digital concepts into clear, actionable strategies is what sets her apart.
Scroll to Top