Optimizely vs MonsterInsights: The Best Analytics Tool for You

Choosing between Optimizely & MonsterInsights? Our side-by-side comparison helps you decide which analytics tool elevates your web strategy.

When it comes to carving out a successful path in the digital world, choosing the right CRM tool is akin to selecting the best guide for a journey through uncharted territories. With a myriad of options available, each promising to be the compass that navigates you through the dense forest of digital marketing strategies, it’s crucial to make an informed choice. Among the contenders, Optimizely and MonsterInsights stand out, but for very different reasons. One is a master of experimentation, the other, a wizard of insights. Let’s embark on an exploratory quest to determine which tool, Optimizely or MonsterInsights, could be the best CRM tool for you, starting with their prowess in Data Insights and Analytics.

Optimizely MonsterInsights
Optimizely MonsterInsights
G2 Score -4.3 out of 5G2 Score -4.4 out of 5
TrustRadius Score -8.6 out of 10TrustRadius Score -NA

Data Insights and Analytics: The Map to Treasure

In the quest for digital dominance, data insights and analytics are the treasure maps that guide marketers to the X marking the spot of conversion gold. How Optimizely and MonsterInsights fare in unearthing these treasures could very well determine which tool is the right companion for your journey.

Optimizely: The Experimentation Pathfinder

Optimizely, at its core, is an experimenter’s dream. Designed to test the waters before diving in, it offers a platform where every hypothesis can be tested, and every intuition can be validated through A/B testing. But it’s not just about throwing ideas at the wall to see what sticks; it’s about strategic experimentation informed by solid data insights.

The platform excels in providing real-time analytics that empower marketers to make informed decisions quickly. Optimizely allows you to track how variations perform against key metrics, giving you the agility to adapt strategies on the fly. This dynamic approach to analytics ensures that you’re not just collecting data; you’re actively using it to steer the ship towards success.

MonsterInsights: The Analytics Conductor

MonsterInsights, on the other hand, brings Google Analytics data straight to your WordPress dashboard, making it a beacon for those seeking clarity in the chaos of website data. It’s about seeing the forest and the trees—offering both a bird’s eye view of your site’s performance and the granular details of user interactions.

With MonsterInsights, the focus is on simplifying complex data sets into actionable insights. From tracking website visitors and understanding their behavior to monitoring conversion rates across different channels, MonsterInsights aims to be the compass that guides your strategy with precision. It’s the tool for those who believe the devil (and the treasure) is in the details.

Pricing and Value: The Cost of the Quest

In every quest, the heroes must consider their resources and the value of the treasures they seek. Optimizely and MonsterInsights offer different treasures, each with its own cost and value to those who choose to embark on a journey with them.

Optimizely: Customized Treasures for Bold Adventurers


Optimizely offers a treasure chest that is not one-size-fits-all but is instead customized to fit the size and ambition of each adventurer’s quest. Pricing for Optimizely’s services is not displayed openly like a tavern’s menu; instead, it requires a dialogue with their seers (sales team) to tailor a package that matches your needs. This approach allows for a high degree of customization, ensuring that you pay for the magic and might you need for your specific battles and not for unnecessary spells.

The value of Optimizely lies in its powerful experimentation and personalization capabilities, designed to significantly enhance the user experience and conversion rates on your digital properties. The cost of these services can vary widely depending on the scale of your operations and the depth of functionality you require. For kingdoms large and small, the investment in Optimizely is an investment in the power to shape the digital realm to your will, with the promise of increased treasures (revenue) through improved user engagement.

MonsterInsights: Clear Pricing for Kingdoms Great and Small


MonsterInsights takes a different approach, displaying its pricing and packages like a map for all to see. This transparency allows small hamlets and great kingdoms alike to quickly assess whether MonsterInsights’ magic is within their budget and how it aligns with their quest’s objectives. With tiered pricing plans, MonsterInsights caters to a range of adventurers, from those just starting out to those commanding vast digital landscapes.

The value of MonsterInsights is in its ability to demystify the complex scrolls of Google Analytics, making the data accessible and actionable within the familiar walls of WordPress. For those whose quests primarily unfold on WordPress, MonsterInsights offers a powerful lens through which to view the behaviors and preferences of their subjects, empowering them with the knowledge to make informed decisions and adjustments to their strategies.

Integration Capabilities: Forming Alliances in the Digital Seas

A digital marketing tool’s power is often measured not only by its standalone capabilities but also by how well it integrates with other tools in your arsenal, from content management systems and email marketing platforms to data analytics suites and advertising networks.

Optimizely: The Versatile Voyager

Optimizely prides itself on being a versatile voyager, offering broad integration capabilities that allow it to dock seamlessly with a myriad of digital marketing tools and platforms. Whether you’re looking to integrate with content management systems like WordPress, e-commerce platforms such as Shopify, or analytics tools including Google Analytics, Optimizely is designed to connect effortlessly, enhancing the reach and effectiveness of your experiments and personalization strategies.

The platform acts as a central hub from which you can dispatch your marketing strategies across various channels, ensuring consistency and cohesion. Optimizely’s ability to integrate with A/B testing and personalization across web, mobile, and even in emerging digital realms ensures that your marketing efforts are amplified, no matter where your audience may be.

MonsterInsights: The Specialist Scout

MonsterInsights, with its focus on bringing the power of Google Analytics directly into your WordPress dashboard, specializes in navigating the specific waters of WordPress sites. Its strength lies in its ability to make detailed website analytics accessible directly within the WordPress environment, reducing the need to navigate the sometimes treacherous waters of Google Analytics itself.

While MonsterInsights may not boast the broad integration capabilities of Optimizely, it excels in its specialized role, offering a suite of add-ons that enhance its functionality within the WordPress ecosystem. This includes seamless connections with popular WordPress plugins and e-commerce solutions, ensuring that you have a clear view of your website’s performance and user behavior.

WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Customer Support and Educational Resources: Navigating With Support

In the vast expanse of digital marketing, the support and resources provided by your chosen tool can act as a lighthouse, guiding you through foggy uncertainties and offering safe passage through learning curves.

Optimizely: Guiding Light of Experimentation

Optimizely shines brightly when it comes to supporting its users on their journey of experimentation and optimization. Recognizing that each voyage may encounter unique challenges, Optimizely offers a comprehensive suite of support options designed to cater to the needs of all travelers, whether they’re just setting sail or are seasoned navigators of digital waters.

The cornerstone of Optimizely’s support system is its knowledge base, a well-stocked library of articles, tutorials, and best practices that users can access at any time to find guidance and insights. For more personalized assistance, Optimizely provides direct support through email and chat, ensuring that users can quickly find answers to their pressing questions.

Beyond reactive support, Optimizely invests in the growth and education of its users through Optimizely Academy. This platform offers courses and certifications that cover a range of topics, from the basics of A/B testing to advanced personalization strategies, empowering users to enhance their skills and master the art of experimentation.

MonsterInsights: The Compass of WordPress Analytics

MonsterInsights, with its focus on simplifying Google Analytics for WordPress users, understands the importance of providing clear and accessible support to help users make the most of their analytics tools. The platform offers a robust knowledge base that includes detailed guides, how-to articles, and FAQs, designed to help users navigate through common queries and issues with ease.

For users seeking more interactive support, MonsterInsights provides assistance via a ticket-based system, ensuring that specific concerns and challenges are addressed by the support team promptly. While MonsterInsights might not offer the same level of direct communication as Optimizely, its commitment to user support is evident in the quality and comprehensiveness of its resources.

In addition to its support services, MonsterInsights encourages user education through its blog, which is regularly updated with articles on analytics best practices, WordPress tips, and the latest updates to the platform, helping users stay ahead in the ever-evolving landscape of digital marketing.

Scalability and Flexibility: Adapting to the Winds of Change

In the ever-evolving realm of digital marketing, the tools at your disposal must not only serve your current needs but also have the foresight and flexibility to evolve with your ambitions.

Optimizely: The Agile Innovator

Optimizely, known for its prowess in experimentation, also excels in the realm of scalability and flexibility. This platform is designed to grow with your kingdom, accommodating the ever-expanding scope of your digital experiments and personalization efforts. Whether you’re a burgeoning startup or a formidable enterprise, Optimizely’s platform can scale to meet the demands of your campaigns, increasing its capacity for experiments and data analysis as your audience and ambitions grow.

Flexibility lies at the heart of Optimizely’s offering. Its platform is not a rigid fortress but more like a versatile stronghold, capable of adapting its defenses and strategies to meet the changing tides of digital engagement. This allows you to tailor and tweak your experiments with precision, ensuring that your marketing efforts remain dynamic and responsive to your audience’s evolving preferences.

MonsterInsights: The Stalwart Guide

MonsterInsights, with its deep integration into WordPress, provides a different kind of scalability and flexibility. It’s a tool that’s as suitable for the small fiefdoms as it is for vast empires, primarily due to its simplicity and the universal value of the insights it provides. As your realm grows, so too does the volume of data you’ll need to analyze. MonsterInsights scales effortlessly, continuing to offer clear, actionable insights regardless of the size of your traffic or the complexity of your site.

Flexibility in MonsterInsights comes from its ability to integrate with a variety of WordPress plugins and online commerce platforms, ensuring that as your digital presence diversifies, your ability to understand and act on your data remains uncompromised. This makes MonsterInsights a reliable guide through the complexities of website analytics, always ready to offer insights and clarity no matter how your kingdom expands.


As we conclude our exploratory journey comparing Optimizely and MonsterInsights, we’ve ventured through critical territories that define the essence and capability of each tool. From the analytical depths of Data Insights and Analytics to the strategic landscapes of Integration Capabilities, and navigating the supportive realms of Customer Support and Educational Resources, we’ve charted the paths these tools carve through the digital marketing domain. We’ve assessed their Pricing and Value, unveiling the investment required to harness their powers, and finally, we’ve scaled the peaks of Scalability and Flexibility, understanding their capacity to grow and adapt with your kingdom.


Scroll to Top