iContact vs Mailshake: The Best Email Marketing Tool for You

Choosing the right email marketing tool is crucial! Explore our comparison of iContact vs Mailshake to find the perfect solution for your business success. Dive in now!

Hey there! Today, we’re embarking on a journey to discover the ideal email marketing tool for your needs. In the spotlight are iContact and Mailshake, two popular choices in the email marketing world. This isn’t just about picking a winner; it’s about finding which tool fits like a glove for your unique marketing strategies. So, let’s dive into our first area of comparison and see how these two contenders measure up.

G2 Score – 4.1 out of 5 stars
G2 Score –  4.7 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score -7.7 out of 10TrustRadius Score – 8.6 out of 10

User Experience: Navigating the Platforms

In the world of email marketing, the user experience (UX) can be a deal-breaker. It’s the difference between a smooth sail and a choppy ride. Let’s compare iContact and Mailshake in terms of their user-friendliness and overall user experience.

iContact: The Intuitive Navigator

iContact is often celebrated for its intuitive and user-friendly interface. It’s like walking into a well-organized room where everything is right where you need it.

From the get-go, iContact makes things simple. The dashboard is straightforward, making it easy for even the most novice users to navigate. Setting up a campaign is a breeze, thanks to the drag-and-drop editor that lets you craft your emails without needing to be a tech wizard.

iContact is like the friendly guide in your email marketing journey. With helpful prompts and an easily navigable interface, it ensures that you’re never lost or overwhelmed. This makes it particularly appealing for small business owners or those just starting with email marketing.

Mailshake: The Advanced Explorer

Mailshake takes a different approach, offering a platform that’s rich in features and possibilities. It’s like being handed the keys to a high-tech vehicle with all the bells and whistles.

While Mailshake packs a punch in terms of capabilities, it does come with a steeper learning curve. The interface is designed for those who have a bit more experience in email marketing. It’s great for users who want more control and advanced features but might be a bit much for absolute beginners.

For the seasoned marketer, Mailshake offers a playground of features. From automated sequences to detailed tracking, it provides tools that can significantly enhance your outreach campaigns. It’s like having a Swiss Army knife – incredibly useful, as long as you know how to use it.

The UX Verdict

Choosing between iContact and Mailshake in terms of user experience boils down to your comfort level with technology and your specific needs.

  • If you value ease of use, straightforward navigation, and a gentle learning curve, iContact is likely your best bet. It’s ideal for those who want efficiency without complexity.
  • However, if you’re comfortable with a bit more complexity and are looking for a feature-rich platform, Mailshake could be your go-to. Its advanced features are well-suited for users who want to dive deep into the nuances of email outreach.

Feature Set: The Heart of Email Marketing Tools

Diving deeper into our comparison, let’s explore the feature sets of iContact and Mailshake. The right features can turn your email marketing efforts from good to great, so understanding what each platform offers is key to making an informed decision.

iContact: A Balanced Feature Portfolio

iContact is like a well-stocked toolbox – it has a variety of tools that are handy for most email marketing tasks.

iContact offers a wide range of email templates, making it easy to create professional-looking emails quickly. These templates are not only diverse but also customizable, allowing you to infuse your brand’s personality into your communications.

Automation is one of iContact’s strong suits. You can set up automated email sequences that trigger based on specific subscriber actions. This feature is invaluable for nurturing leads and keeping your audience engaged with minimal manual effort.

iContact integrates smoothly with many popular CRM systems, social media platforms, and other marketing tools. These integrations are crucial for creating a cohesive digital marketing strategy, ensuring that your email campaigns work hand in hand with your other marketing efforts.

Mailshake: Advanced Features for Power Users

Mailshake, on the other hand, is like a high-tech gadget with specialized features for the power user.

Mailshake’s standout feature is its focus on cold email outreach. It offers advanced personalization options and templates specifically designed for outreach campaigns, which is a boon for sales and PR professionals.

Mailshake provides comprehensive tracking features, allowing you to monitor the performance of your outreach campaigns closely. You can track opens, clicks, replies, and more, giving you a clear picture of how your recipients are engaging with your emails.

Automation in Mailshake is particularly robust, with the ability to set up complex sequences and conditional follow-ups. This can significantly increase your engagement rates, especially in cold outreach scenarios where follow-up is key.

Feature Set Showdown

When it comes to features, your choice between iContact and Mailshake will largely depend on your specific email marketing needs.

  • iContact is a great option if you need a well-rounded tool that covers all the bases of traditional email marketing. Its range of templates, automation capabilities, and integrations make it a versatile choice for most businesses.
  • Mailshake is more tailored for users who focus on cold outreach and sales. Its advanced personalization, detailed tracking, and sophisticated automation make it ideal for businesses looking to enhance their outreach efforts.

Pricing Structures: Matching Your Budget with Your Needs

In the world of email marketing tools, pricing can be as varied as the features they offer. Understanding the pricing structures of iContact and Mailshake is crucial to ensuring you get the best value for your money. Let’s delve into how these two platforms price their services and what they offer at different price points.

iContactBase Plan: Pricing starts at around $30/month for 500 subscribers and includes features like drag-and-drop editing, detailed tracking, and autoresponders.
Pro Plan: Starting at approximately $45/month for 500 subscribers, adding features like workflow automation, landing pages, and segmentation.
Custom pricing is available for higher volume needs and more advanced features.
MailshakeEmail Outreach Plan: Priced at $59/user/month when billed annually. Includes features like email personalization, lead catchers, and analytics.
Sales Engagement Plan: Priced at $99/user/month when billed annually. Includes additional features like phone dialer, social selling, and Salesforce integration.
Both plans offer features tailored for sales teams and agencies focusing on cold email outreach and sales engagement.

iContact: Clear and Scalable Pricing

iContact’s pricing model is designed to be transparent and grow with your business, making it a viable option for a range of budgets.

iContact employs a tiered pricing system, where the cost escalates with the increase in the number of subscribers. This approach is user-friendly, allowing businesses to choose a plan that aligns with their size and email list. It’s akin to stepping up a ladder – you move to the next rung as your needs grow.

Even at its most basic tier, iContact offers a solid array of features including access to their email templates, automation tools, and basic analytics. As you move up the pricing tiers, you gain access to more advanced features, accommodating the needs of larger businesses or more complex email marketing strategies.

Mailshake: Flexible Pricing for Outreach

Mailshake takes a slightly different approach, tailoring its pricing to cater to businesses focused on outreach and sales.

Mailshake’s pricing is based on the features and scale of outreach efforts rather than the size of your email list. This can be particularly beneficial for businesses that engage in heavy outreach campaigns but don’t necessarily have a large subscriber base.

Regardless of the plan you choose, Mailshake emphasizes features that enhance outreach capabilities. This includes advanced personalization, automated sequences, and detailed tracking – all crucial for effective cold emailing and sales prospecting.

Weighing the Cost Against Benefits

Deciding between iContact and Mailshake in terms of pricing involves considering your specific marketing needs and how they align with what each platform offers.

  • If you’re looking for a straightforward, scalable solution that caters to traditional email marketing, iContact is a solid choice. Its tiered pricing model makes it suitable for a wide range of businesses, from small startups to larger enterprises.
  • For businesses with a strong focus on sales and outreach, Mailshake’s pricing structure offers targeted value. Its plans are tailored to enhance outreach efforts, making it ideal for users who prioritize these activities in their marketing strategy.
WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Related: Check out our free SEO suite

Free SEO Suite by WinSavvy

Integration Capabilities: Connecting Your Marketing Stack

The ability of an email marketing tool to integrate with other software and services can significantly streamline your marketing efforts. Let’s compare the integration capabilities of iContact and Mailshake to see how well they play with other tools in your marketing stack.

iContact: Seamless Integration for a Unified Approach

iContact is designed to easily integrate with a variety of popular business tools, ensuring your marketing efforts are cohesive and streamlined.

iContact offers integrations with major CRM platforms, social media networks, and eCommerce tools. This broad range of integrations is crucial for businesses that rely on a diverse set of tools for their marketing and sales processes. It’s like having a universal remote that controls all your devices.

For tools that don’t have a direct integration, iContact connects with Zapier, expanding its integration capabilities significantly. Through Zapier, iContact can link with hundreds of other applications, automating tasks between your email marketing and other business processes.

Mailshake: Specialized Integrations for Outreach

Mailshake, with its focus on email outreach, offers a different set of integration capabilities tailored to its core functionality.

Mailshake integrates with CRM software, LinkedIn, and other tools that are particularly useful for sales and outreach activities. These integrations allow for a more streamlined process in managing outreach campaigns, from lead generation to follow-up.

For more specialized needs, Mailshake provides API access, enabling businesses to create custom integrations. This feature is especially beneficial for businesses with unique systems or those who require more sophisticated integrations that go beyond standard offerings.

Integration as a Key Factor

Choosing between iContact and Mailshake for integration capabilities should be based on your specific marketing technology needs and the complexity of your campaigns.

  • If you require a wide range of integrations that cover various aspects of your business, iContact is a great option. Its ability to integrate with numerous platforms and services via direct integration and Zapier makes it a versatile choice for many businesses.
  • For those who need more specialized integrations, particularly in the realm of sales and outreach, Mailshake offers targeted solutions. Its direct integrations and API access provide the tools needed for advanced outreach strategies.

Analytics and Reporting: Gaining Insights from Your Campaigns

In email marketing, the ability to analyze and understand your campaign performance is crucial. It helps you make data-driven decisions and refine your strategies. Let’s delve into the analytics and reporting features of iContact and Mailshake to see which tool provides the insights that can drive your marketing efforts forward.

iContact: User-Friendly Analytics for Informed Strategies

iContact offers analytics that are both comprehensive and easy to understand, catering to a wide range of users.

With iContact, you get a straightforward analytics dashboard that provides essential metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and subscriber growth. This clarity is particularly useful for businesses that need quick insights to inform their decisions without getting bogged down in data complexity.

Beyond basic metrics, iContact provides deeper insights into subscriber behavior and campaign effectiveness. This allows you to tailor your future campaigns for better engagement, making your email marketing more effective over time.

Mailshake: Detailed Analytics for Outreach Mastery

Mailshake, with its focus on outreach, offers a different angle on analytics and reporting, providing detailed data that’s crucial for sales and PR campaigns.

Mailshake’s analytics are robust, offering in-depth tracking of opens, clicks, replies, and more. This level of detail is invaluable for outreach campaigns, where understanding recipient engagement can significantly impact your strategy.

The reporting in Mailshake is tailored to the needs of sales and PR professionals. It provides detailed insights into the performance of outreach campaigns, allowing users to fine-tune their approach for maximum effectiveness.

Analytics: Choosing What Matters to You

When it comes to analytics and reporting, the choice between iContact and Mailshake depends on the type of insights you need for your campaigns.

  • If you’re looking for user-friendly analytics that provide a clear overview of your campaign performance with actionable insights, iContact is an excellent choice. Its straightforward reporting is ideal for businesses that need to quickly assess and adjust their email marketing strategies.
  • For businesses focused on outreach, where detailed tracking and tailored analytics are crucial, Mailshake is the better fit. Its in-depth reporting features cater to the specific needs of sales and PR campaigns, providing the detailed data necessary to optimize outreach efforts.

Customer Support and Community: The Lifeline of Your Marketing Efforts

The quality of customer support and the presence of a supportive community can significantly influence your experience with an email marketing tool. Let’s examine how iContact and Mailshake support their users, not just through customer service but also by fostering a community of engaged users.

iContact: Personalized Support and Rich Resources

iContact is known for providing a high level of customer support, which can be a deciding factor for many businesses.

iContact offers various channels for customer support, including email, phone, and live chat. This multi-channel approach ensures that help is always just a few clicks or a phone call away. Users often praise the responsiveness and helpfulness of the iContact support team, which can be a big relief, especially in time-sensitive situations.

Beyond direct support, iContact provides an abundance of learning resources. These include webinars, tutorials, and a rich knowledge base filled with articles on best practices. For those who like to self-educate or need a quick solution, these resources are invaluable.

Mailshake: Focused Support for Outreach

Mailshake, with its emphasis on sales and PR outreach, tailors its customer support to cater to these specific needs.

Mailshake offers detailed and technical support, particularly useful for users with advanced needs or those utilizing the platform for complex outreach campaigns. Their support team is equipped to handle in-depth queries, ensuring that users can make the most out of the tool’s advanced features.

Mailshake fosters a community of users, which is particularly beneficial for sharing strategies, tips, and real-life experiences. This peer-to-peer interaction can be a goldmine of information, especially in the nuanced realm of sales and PR outreach.

The Support You Need

Choosing between iContact and Mailshake in terms of customer support and community engagement depends on your preferences and the level of support you anticipate needing.

  • If you value personalized, easily accessible support and a wealth of educational resources to guide your email marketing journey, iContact is a great choice. Its approachable support team and extensive learning materials are well-suited for a wide range of users.
  • For those who require more specialized support, particularly in the realm of sales and outreach, and value community interaction for advanced strategies, Mailshake is the better fit. Its focus on providing in-depth support and fostering a community for outreach professionals makes it ideal for users with specific, advanced needs.


In wrapping up our exploration of iContact and Mailshake, it’s clear that both platforms cater to distinct needs within the realm of email marketing. iContact emerges as a user-friendly option, ideal for small to medium-sized businesses or those just starting out in email marketing. Its intuitive interface, combined with a comprehensive set of features, makes it a reliable and efficient choice for managing a variety of email marketing campaigns. The platform’s strength in customer support and rich educational resources further enhances its appeal to users seeking a supportive and easy-to-navigate marketing tool.

On the other hand, Mailshake presents itself as a robust tool specifically tailored for sales and PR professionals focused on outreach. Its advanced features, particularly in campaign tracking and automation, are well-suited for users who require detailed analytics and specialized functionalities for targeted outreach efforts. The platform’s specialized customer support and active user community offer additional value, especially for those who delve deep into the nuances of outreach and sales-driven campaigns.

Read next:

author avatar
Poulomi Chakraborty
Poulomi Chakraborty is at the heart of our digital marketing team at WinSavvy. With a keen grasp on the ever-evolving world of SEO and digital trends, she is known for her thoughtful and strategic approach. Poulomi blends deep industry knowledge with a genuine enthusiasm for helping businesses shine online. Her ability to translate complex digital concepts into clear, actionable strategies is what sets her apart.
Scroll to Top