VerticalResponse vs Campaigner: The Best Email Marketing Tool for You

Maximize your email impact! Explore VerticalResponse vs Campaigner to choose the perfect tool for effective campaigns and seamless audience engagement.

Email marketing isn’t just a way to reach out to customers; it’s an art of connecting, engaging, and converting your audience into loyal fans. In today’s digital landscape, the tools you use can make a massive difference in this art. Two popular names in this arena are VerticalResponse and Campaigner. But which one is the perfect fit for your business? Let’s dive in and explore, starting with one of the most crucial aspects – user experience.

G2 Score – 3.3 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – 3.6 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score -10.0 out of 10TrustRadius Score – 2.4 out of 10

User Experience: The First Date with Your Email Tool

Think of the first time you use an email marketing tool as a first date. It’s all about the initial impression, ease of interaction, and whether it feels right. Let’s see how VerticalResponse and Campaigner fare in this all-important aspect.

VerticalResponse: The Approachable Companion

When you first log into VerticalResponse, it’s like walking into a well-organized, welcoming space. Everything feels intuitive and friendly. For those who are not tech wizards or just starting out with email marketing, this is a huge relief. The platform is designed to make you feel at home quickly.

Creating an email campaign in VerticalResponse is akin to having a smooth conversation. There’s a natural flow to adding contacts, choosing templates, and crafting your message. The drag-and-drop editor is a breeze to use, allowing you to design emails without needing to know a single line of code. It’s like having a chat over coffee – relaxed and effortless.

But ease doesn’t mean basic. VerticalResponse packs a punch with its customization options. You can tweak templates to match your brand, ensuring your emails resonate with your audience. It’s like having a conversation where you can effortlessly bring your personality into play.

Campaigner: The Detail-Oriented Partner

Campaigner, in contrast, is like a date who loves details and depth. The interface is more robust and might seem overwhelming at first glance, especially if you’re new to email marketing. But once you get the hang of it, you realize the power it holds.

The platform offers a myriad of features and customization options, making it a haven for marketers who love to dive deep into crafting their emails. The editor offers intricate control over design elements, allowing you to fine-tune every aspect of your email. It’s like having a deep, engaging conversation where every detail is acknowledged and appreciated.

Campaigner’s strength lies in its ability to cater to nuanced needs. You can segment your audience with precision, create highly targeted campaigns, and analyze results in-depth. It’s for those who enjoy a relationship where intricacies and nuances are not just understood but also valued.

The First Impression Verdict

If you’re looking for an email marketing tool that’s easy to get along with, makes you feel comfortable from the get-go, and still lets you express your brand’s personality, VerticalResponse is your match. It’s perfect for small businesses or anyone starting their journey in email marketing.

On the other hand, if you’re someone who appreciates depth, detail, and the ability to micro-manage every aspect of your email campaigns, Campaigner could be your ideal partner. It’s suited for marketers who are experienced and have specific, detailed needs from their email tool.

Automation Features: Streamlining Your Email Campaigns

In the world of email marketing, automation is like having a reliable assistant who takes care of the repetitive tasks, allowing you to focus on the creative and strategic aspects. Let’s delve into how VerticalResponse and Campaigner handle automation and what it means for your email marketing efforts.

VerticalResponse: Simplifying Automation

VerticalResponse treats automation like a helpful friend who takes chores off your hands. Its automation features are designed to be straightforward and easy to set up. You can automate basic yet crucial tasks like sending welcome emails to new subscribers or thank-you emails after a purchase. This kind of automation is not just a time-saver; it also ensures consistent communication with your audience.

The platform allows you to create autoresponder sequences, which are great for nurturing leads. For instance, you can set up a series of emails that guide a new subscriber through your product range or share helpful content over a period. This automated journey keeps your audience engaged without requiring your constant attention.

Campaigner: Advanced Automation for the Power User

Campaigner approaches automation like a seasoned assistant who’s ready to take on complex tasks. It offers a more advanced set of automation features compared to VerticalResponse. With Campaigner, you can create intricate workflow automations based on subscriber actions, preferences, and behavior.

The platform provides the capability to design multi-step, conditional workflows. For example, you can set up a campaign where subscribers who clicked on a link in your email receive a different follow-up than those who didn’t. This level of automation sophistication allows for highly personalized and effective email campaigns.

Moreover, Campaigner’s automation extends to list management as well. It can automatically segment your list based on subscriber behavior, ensuring that your messages are always targeted to the right audience. This feature is invaluable for marketers looking to maximize engagement and conversions.

Weighing Automation Capabilities

When it comes to automation, your choice between VerticalResponse and Campaigner depends on the complexity of your needs. If you’re looking for an easy-to-use tool that covers the basics of email automation, VerticalResponse is your go-to. It’s ideal for those who want to automate key parts of their email marketing without getting into too technical details.

Campaigner, with its advanced automation features, is perfect for the power user who wants to dive deep into personalized and behavior-based email marketing. It’s a fit for businesses that require sophisticated, targeted campaigns driven by subscriber behavior.

Automation is a key component in scaling your email marketing efforts effectively. The right tool should not only save you time but also enhance your ability to connect with your audience in a meaningful way.

Integration and Compatibility: Connecting Your Marketing Ecosystem

In today’s digital marketing landscape, the ability of your email marketing tool to integrate with other software and services is vital. It’s about creating a seamless flow of data and processes across your marketing ecosystem. Let’s compare how VerticalResponse and Campaigner handle integrations and compatibility.

VerticalResponse: Effortless Connectivity for the Essentials

VerticalResponse offers a range of integration options that cover the essential needs of most small to medium-sized businesses. It seamlessly connects with popular CRM systems, social media platforms, and e-commerce solutions. This compatibility is key for businesses looking to synchronize their email marketing with other aspects of their digital strategy.

For instance, integrating VerticalResponse with your CRM system can streamline your contact management. This means less time spent on manual data entry and more time for strategic planning. Similarly, connecting it with e-commerce platforms can help in automating emails based on purchase behavior, enhancing the relevance and timing of your communication.

Campaigner: Robust Integration for the Advanced Marketer

Campaigner takes integrations a notch higher, offering a wide array of options that cater to more advanced marketing needs. It’s designed to fit into a complex marketing tech stack, providing the flexibility and compatibility required by larger businesses or those with intricate marketing processes.

With Campaigner, you have the ability to integrate with advanced CRM systems, deep analytics tools, and a variety of third-party applications. This level of integration capability allows for more detailed data flow and segmentation, leading to highly targeted and personalized email campaigns.

Moreover, Campaigner’s API access offers the possibility of custom integrations. This is particularly beneficial for businesses with unique needs that require tailor-made solutions to sync their various marketing tools seamlessly.

Integration as a Strategic Factor

Choosing between VerticalResponse and Campaigner in terms of integration depends on the complexity of your marketing ecosystem. VerticalResponse is well-suited for businesses that need straightforward, essential integrations without the bells and whistles. It’s ideal if you’re looking for simplicity and ease of use in syncing your email marketing with other tools.

Campaigner, on the other hand, is the choice for businesses that require a high level of integration complexity. Its wide range of options and custom API access make it a strong candidate for those who need deep, sophisticated integration capabilities.

Integrations play a crucial role in creating an efficient and cohesive digital marketing strategy. The right email marketing tool should not only fit seamlessly into your current tech stack but also adapt to your evolving business needs.

Pricing Comparison: VerticalResponse vs Campaigner

In the digital marketing ecosystem, selecting the right email marketing platform can significantly influence the success of your campaigns. VerticalResponse and Campaigner are two notable solutions in this space, each catering to different user needs with their unique features and pricing models. VerticalResponse is often favored by small businesses and nonprofits for its simplicity and ease of use, while Campaigner targets a broader audience with its advanced automation features and scalability. This comparison aims to provide a detailed overview of the pricing structures of VerticalResponse and Campaigner, helping marketers choose the platform that best fits their budget and marketing requirements.

VerticalResponseFree Plan: Offers up to 300 emails per month to up to 300 contacts.
Basic Plan: Starting around $11/month for up to 500 contacts, offering unlimited emails and more tools.
Pro Plan: Starting from around $16/month for up to 500 contacts, adding advanced features like automated follow-up emails, landing pages, and email scheduling.
Pro+ Plan: Offers full-service email marketing starting around $196 per month, where a team of experts designs and sends your emails for you.
CampaignerStarter Plan: Begins around $59 per month for up to 5,000 contacts, including basic email marketing features and 24/7 support.
Essential Plan: Priced around $179 per month for up to 25,000 contacts, adding features like advanced segmentation and A/B testing.
Advanced Plan: Starting from around $649 per month for up to 50,000 contacts, offering advanced automation, reporting, and integrations.
eCommerce Plan: Designed specifically for eCommerce businesses with custom pricing, including features like purchase behavior tracking and predictive analytics.

VerticalResponse Pricing Overview

VerticalResponse is designed to cater to small businesses and organizations looking for an intuitive and straightforward email marketing solution. It emphasizes user-friendliness and efficiency, making it a popular choice for those new to email marketing or with limited technical resources.

VerticalResponse offers a free tier that allows users to send a limited number of emails per month, making it an attractive option for small businesses or startups just beginning their email marketing efforts. This plan includes basic features such as email creation tools, contact management, and reporting. For users with more extensive needs, VerticalResponse provides tiered pricing plans based on the volume of emails sent, without imposing limits on the number of contacts. These paid plans introduce additional features like advanced reporting, automated follow-up emails, and social media integration.

The platform’s pricing model is flexible, scaling with the volume of emails sent. This approach allows businesses to control costs by adjusting their email marketing volume as needed. VerticalResponse also offers pay-as-you-go options for those with irregular sending needs, adding to its flexibility.

Campaigner Pricing Overview

Campaigner is recognized for its robust email marketing and automation capabilities, catering to a wide range of businesses from small to large enterprises. It offers a comprehensive set of features designed to support complex email marketing strategies, including advanced segmentation, automation workflows, and detailed analytics.

Unlike VerticalResponse, Campaigner does not offer a free tier. Instead, it provides a more granular set of tiered pricing plans based on the number of contacts, allowing businesses to select a plan that best matches their list size and feature requirements. Each tier includes access to all of Campaigner’s features, with price adjustments based on contact quantity rather than email volume. This makes Campaigner a scalable solution for growing businesses.

Campaigner’s pricing strategy emphasizes value by offering comprehensive access to its features across all plans, with costs scaling based on the size of the user’s contact list. This model supports businesses as they grow, ensuring they have access to advanced marketing tools without needing to upgrade to higher-tier plans. Campaigner also occasionally offers promotions and discounts, providing additional value to long-term users.

Comparative Insights

When comparing VerticalResponse and Campaigner, several key aspects stand out:

  • Ease of Use vs. Advanced Features: VerticalResponse is designed for simplicity and ease of use, making it ideal for small businesses or those just starting with email marketing. Campaigner, with its advanced features, targets businesses looking for more sophisticated email marketing capabilities and automation.
  • Pricing Structure: VerticalResponse’s volume-based pricing offers flexibility for businesses with varying email marketing needs, including a free tier for very small campaigns. Campaigner’s contact-based pricing, while lacking a free option, provides comprehensive feature access, making it suitable for businesses ready to invest in more complex campaigns.
  • Target Audience: VerticalResponse caters to small businesses and nonprofits that require a straightforward solution. Campaigner is aimed at a broader audience, including those with more extensive email marketing needs and a desire for detailed campaign customization and automation.

Deciding between VerticalResponse and Campaigner should be based on your specific marketing needs, budget, and the complexity of the campaigns you plan to run. VerticalResponse offers an affordable and user-friendly platform for small businesses and beginners, while Campaigner provides a more feature-rich environment suited to businesses looking to execute advanced email marketing strategies. By carefully considering your requirements and the capabilities of each platform, you can make an informed decision that ensures the success of your email marketing initiatives.

WinSavvy helps VC-Funded Startups scale their digital marketing with a focus on SEO and social media retargeting.
Click here to learn more!

Analytics and Reporting: Gleaning Insights from Your Campaigns

The true power of email marketing lies in understanding how your campaigns perform and using those insights to make informed decisions. Both VerticalResponse and Campaigner offer analytics and reporting features, but they cater to different needs and preferences. Let’s explore how each platform helps you measure success and refine your strategies.

VerticalResponse: Clarity in Numbers

VerticalResponse focuses on providing clear, straightforward analytics that are easy to understand and act upon. When you send out an email campaign, you get access to essential metrics like open rates, click-through rates, and bounce rates. These metrics are presented in a user-friendly format, making it easy for even beginners to understand their campaign’s performance.

Beyond basic metrics, VerticalResponse also offers insights into subscriber engagement over time. This helps you track the long-term effectiveness of your campaigns and understand how your audience’s behavior changes. Additionally, its social media reporting integrates your email campaign performance with your social media activity, offering a more comprehensive view of your digital marketing efforts.

Campaigner: Deep Diving into Data

Campaigner takes analytics and reporting to a more advanced level, ideal for those who love to dive deep into data. It offers detailed reports that go beyond the basics, allowing you to analyze various aspects of your email campaigns in depth.

With Campaigner, you can segment your reports to get insights into specific subscriber groups. This level of detail is invaluable for tailoring your future campaigns to different segments of your audience. Campaigner also enables A/B testing, giving you the ability to test and compare different elements of your emails to see what works best.

Another significant feature is the ability to track conversions and revenue generated from your email campaigns. This is crucial for businesses focused on ROI and looking to directly link their email marketing efforts to sales outcomes.

Making Sense of Your Email Campaigns

In choosing between VerticalResponse and Campaigner for analytics and reporting, consider the depth of insights you need. VerticalResponse is ideal for those who need clear, straightforward metrics and want to understand the basic performance of their campaigns without getting overwhelmed by data.

Campaigner, on the other hand, is suited for marketers who require detailed analytics, want to delve into advanced segmentation, and are keen on directly measuring the impact of their email campaigns on sales and conversions.

Effective email marketing is not just about sending messages; it’s about understanding how those messages perform and using that knowledge to improve. The right tool should empower you with insights while aligning with your comfort level in data analysis.

Deliverability and Reliability: Ensuring Your Emails Reach Their Destination

The success of your email marketing campaigns heavily relies on deliverability – the ability of your emails to successfully land in your recipients’ inboxes. Let’s compare how VerticalResponse and Campaigner ensure the deliverability and reliability of your emails.

VerticalResponse: Dependable Delivery

VerticalResponse places a strong emphasis on ensuring high deliverability rates. The platform takes several measures to make sure your emails don’t end up in the spam folder. This includes maintaining compliance with email sending best practices and offering tools to optimize your email content for better inbox placement.

Additionally, VerticalResponse provides a feature to test the deliverability of your emails before you send them out. This preemptive step allows you to tweak your emails to avoid spam filters, thereby increasing the chances of reaching your audience effectively.

Campaigner: Advanced Deliverability Features

Campaigner approaches deliverability with a more technical bent, offering advanced features to maximize your email’s chances of reaching the inbox. It includes sophisticated list management tools that help you maintain a clean and engaged email list, a critical factor in improving deliverability.

Moreover, Campaigner offers detailed reports on deliverability metrics, allowing you to analyze and understand any issues that might be affecting your email performance. This level of insight is particularly useful for businesses with large email lists or those that send high volumes of emails.

Ensuring Your Message is Heard

In terms of deliverability, both VerticalResponse and Campaigner are strong contenders. VerticalResponse is great for businesses looking for a reliable platform that ensures emails reach their destination without requiring too much technical involvement. Its user-friendly approach to deliverability makes it accessible for all types of users.

Campaigner, with its advanced deliverability features and detailed analytics, is better suited for businesses that need a more hands-on approach to managing their email deliverability, especially those with large mailing lists or sophisticated email marketing strategies.

Reliable email deliverability is crucial; it’s not just about sending emails, but ensuring they land where they’re supposed to. The right tool will not only help you send your emails but also give you the peace of mind that they’re reaching your audience.

Customer Support and Resources: The Lifeline of Your Email Marketing Tool

Having robust customer support and access to comprehensive resources can be a game-changer in your email marketing journey. Let’s explore how VerticalResponse and Campaigner support their users through customer service and educational materials.

VerticalResponse: Support with a Personal Touch

VerticalResponse offers a range of support options designed to cater to the needs of different users. The platform provides direct support through email, phone, and live chat, ensuring that help is just a message or call away. This can be particularly reassuring for businesses that are new to email marketing or those who prefer having direct assistance.

In addition to its direct support channels, VerticalResponse offers a wealth of online resources. This includes an extensive knowledge base, tutorials, and webinars. These resources are not just about troubleshooting; they also offer insights and tips on how to improve your email marketing strategies. It’s like having a mentor guide you through the nuances of email marketing.

Campaigner: Comprehensive Support for Complex Needs

Campaigner, known for its advanced features, matches this with comprehensive customer support. The platform offers 24/7 support via email, live chat, and phone, providing assistance whenever needed. This round-the-clock support is crucial for businesses that run large-scale, time-sensitive email campaigns.

Beyond direct support, Campaigner also boasts an impressive array of learning resources. This includes detailed guides, video tutorials, and a blog filled with industry insights and tips. For those who want to delve deeper into the technicalities and advanced strategies of email marketing, these resources are invaluable.

Navigating Your Email Marketing Journey

When it comes to customer support and resources, both VerticalResponse and Campaigner excel, albeit in slightly different ways. VerticalResponse is ideal for users who value straightforward support and easy-to-digest resources to help them get up to speed quickly with email marketing.

Campaigner, with its extensive support and in-depth resources, is better suited for users who require a higher level of assistance, particularly those dealing with more complex email marketing strategies or technical issues.

Having reliable customer support and access to educational resources can significantly impact how effectively you use your email marketing tool. The right choice will offer the support you need and resources that align with your level of expertise and the complexities of your campaigns.


In the diverse landscape of email marketing tools, both VerticalResponse and Campaigner stand out, each with its unique strengths catering to different marketing needs. The choice between the two boils down to your specific requirements, preferences, and the scale of your email marketing endeavors.

VerticalResponse shines with its user-friendly interface, making it an excellent choice for those new to email marketing or businesses that prioritize ease of use and simplicity. Its straightforward automation features, reliable deliverability, and personalized customer support make it a dependable option for small to medium-sized businesses.

Campaigner, on the other hand, appeals to the more advanced user. With its robust automation capabilities, intricate deliverability options, and comprehensive support, it suits larger businesses or those with complex email marketing needs. Its depth in analytics and detailed reporting tools are a boon for those who thrive on data-driven strategies.

Read Next:

Scroll to Top