Automizy vs Mailshake: The Best Email Marketing Tool for 2024

Take your email marketing to the next level in 2024! Discover the showdown of Automizy vs Mailshake and choose the perfect tool for successful campaigns

Hey there, savvy marketers and entrepreneurs! If you’re on the hunt for the perfect email marketing tool to skyrocket your campaigns in 2024, you’ve hit the jackpot with this article. Today, we’re diving deep into a head-to-head comparison of two giants in the email marketing arena: Automizy and Mailshake. Forget the tech jargon and boring stats; we’re talking real, actionable insights to help you make the best choice for your business. So, buckle up and let’s get started!

G2 Score – 4.6 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – 4.7 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score – 9.0 out of 10TrustRadius Score – 8.6 out of 10

Ease of Use: A User’s First Impression

In the world of email marketing tools, first impressions matter a lot. Why? Because time is money, and the last thing you want is to spend hours figuring out how to send a simple email. Let’s see how Automizy and Mailshake stack up in terms of ease of use.

Automizy: The User-Friendly Champ?

Automizy prides itself on its user-friendly interface. From the moment you log in, you’re greeted with a clean, intuitive dashboard. It’s like walking into a well-organized room – everything is exactly where you expect it to be. Setting up your first campaign is a breeze. The platform guides you through each step, almost like holding your hand, but without being overbearing.

For beginners, this is a godsend. You don’t feel overwhelmed by a barrage of features and buttons. Instead, Automizy gently introduces its capabilities, letting you explore at your own pace. Creating an email is a mix of simplicity and fun. You have a variety of templates to choose from, and customizing them is as easy as drag-and-drop. No need to be a design whiz; Automizy has got your back.

But here’s the kicker – while Automizy is great for starters, it doesn’t dumb things down for the pros. Underneath its simple exterior lies a powerhouse of features. Advanced users can delve into detailed analytics, A/B testing, and automation workflows that rival the complexity of more ‘serious’ platforms.

Mailshake: Simplicity Meets Power

Mailshake, on the other hand, takes a slightly different approach. It’s like that cool, savvy friend who knows exactly what you need. The platform is straightforward, but don’t let its simplicity fool you. It’s designed primarily for sales professionals and is laser-focused on outreach and follow-up campaigns.

When you start with Mailshake, you’re not inundated with options. Instead, it guides you towards creating effective outreach campaigns. The email creation process is simple, yet powerful. You have the freedom to craft personalized messages that resonate with your audience. Templates are there, but Mailshake encourages a more hands-on approach, pushing you to craft emails that feel personal and less ‘template-y’.

What’s impressive about Mailshake is its seamless integration with various CRM tools and LinkedIn, making it a potent tool for sales and networking. It’s like having an assistant who takes care of the technical stuff, allowing you to focus on building relationships.

So, Who Wins the Ease of Use Battle?

It’s a tough call. If you’re new to email marketing or prefer a more guided experience, Automizy is your go-to tool. It’s friendly, non-intimidating, and makes email marketing feel like a walk in the park. For sales-focused professionals or those who crave simplicity with a punch, Mailshake is your ally. It’s straightforward yet powerful, perfect for crafting personalized outreach campaigns.

In the end, it boils down to your specific needs and preferences. Do you want a gentle introduction to email marketing, or are you looking for a tool that gets straight to the point with sales outreach? Your answer to this question will guide your choice.

Automation and Workflow Capabilities: The Game Changers

In 2024, if your email marketing tool isn’t smart enough to automate tasks and create efficient workflows, you’re basically driving a horse-cart on a Formula 1 track. Let’s see how Automizy and Mailshake fare in this race.

Automizy: The Automation Maestro

Automizy is like a symphony conductor for your email campaigns. It’s not just about sending emails; it’s about sending the right emails at the right time to the right people. The automation features in Automizy are, frankly, impressive. You can set up triggers based on user behavior, like website visits, email opens, or clicks, and let Automizy do the rest.

What’s remarkable about Automizy is its AI-powered subject line tester. You get real-time predictions on how your subject lines will perform, which is like having a crystal ball for your email campaigns. This feature alone can significantly boost your open rates.

The automation workflows are visually appealing and easy to set up. You can create complex sequences of emails based on user actions, ensuring your audience receives personalized and timely content. This level of automation is a massive time-saver and allows you to focus on creating content rather than managing the nitty-gritty of email sending schedules.

Mailshake: Automation for the Sales Driven

Mailshake takes a slightly different approach. While it offers automation features, its strength lies in automating sales outreach and follow-ups. Think of Mailshake as your personal sales automation assistant. It’s not about mass email blasts; it’s about creating targeted, personalized sequences for each prospect.

The platform lets you automate follow-ups based on whether a prospect has opened an email, clicked a link, or replied. This is a game-changer for sales teams because it means you’re always on top of your sales pipeline without having to manually track each interaction.

Mailshake also integrates with phone and social media, allowing you to add calls and social outreach into your automated sequences. This omnichannel approach ensures that your message reaches your prospects through their preferred medium, increasing the chances of engagement.

The Verdict on Automation and Workflows

If your primary goal is to set up sophisticated email marketing campaigns with advanced automation and AI insights, Automizy is the clear winner. Its user-friendly interface combined with powerful automation tools makes it an excellent choice for businesses focused on nurturing leads and personalized customer journeys.

On the other hand, if your focus is on sales and outreach, Mailshake’s targeted automation capabilities make it a formidable tool. Its strength in automating personalized sales sequences and integrating with other outreach channels makes it ideal for sales teams and professionals.

In the end, the choice between Automizy and Mailshake in terms of automation and workflow capabilities boils down to your primary use case: comprehensive email marketing automation or targeted sales outreach automation.

Analytics and Reporting: Measuring Success

Automizy: Data-Driven Decisions Made Easy

Automizy excels in providing detailed analytics and reporting features. It’s like having a magnifying glass that lets you zoom in on every aspect of your email campaigns. The platform offers comprehensive reports that cover all the bases – open rates, click-through rates, bounce rates, and more.

What sets Automizy apart is how it presents this data. The reports are not just a bunch of numbers and charts; they’re insights. For each metric, you get actionable advice on how to improve. For instance, if your open rates are low, Automizy might suggest optimizing your subject lines or sending times.

Another standout feature is the A/B testing results. Automizy doesn’t just tell you which version won; it gives you a detailed breakdown of why it performed better. This insight is invaluable for refining your email strategy over time.

Mailshake: Sales-Centric Reporting

Mailshake, true to its sales-oriented nature, offers analytics and reporting with a focus on sales activities. The platform provides essential email metrics like opens, clicks, and replies, but it goes a step further by integrating these with sales outcomes.

The real power of Mailshake’s reporting lies in its ability to track the entire sales funnel. From the first email sent to the final deal closed, you can see how each step of your outreach campaign contributes to your overall sales goals. This is incredibly useful for sales teams as it allows them to fine-tune their outreach strategies based on what’s driving actual results.

Mailshake also makes it easy to track the performance of individual team members. This feature is a boon for sales managers who need to monitor and optimize their team’s efforts.

The Analytics and Reporting Face-Off

In terms of analytics and reporting, both Automizy and Mailshake shine in their respective areas. Automizy is the go-to tool if you’re looking for in-depth email marketing analytics with actionable insights. Its user-friendly reports and A/B testing analysis are ideal for marketers focused on improving their email engagement metrics.

Mailshake, however, is the better choice for sales-focused teams. Its ability to link email metrics with sales results provides a clear picture of how your outreach efforts are impacting your bottom line. Plus, the team performance tracking is a valuable feature for managing and optimizing sales teams.

Your choice between Automizy and Mailshake for analytics and reporting should align with your primary objective: detailed email marketing insights or sales-focused reporting.

Automizy vs Mailshake: Dissecting Pricing in Email Outreach Platforms

For businesses seeking to maximize their email outreach and engagement, Automizy and Mailshake present themselves as potent tools, each offering a unique set of features and capabilities. However, an integral component of the decision-making process for businesses is understanding the pricing models of these platforms. This article aims to provide a thorough comparison of the pricing strategies of Automizy and Mailshake, enabling businesses to make an informed choice that aligns with their budgetary constraints and marketing objectives.

AutomizyPricing: Automizy offers a tiered pricing structure based on the number of subscribers.
Starting at around $29/month for up to 1,000 subscribers, which includes unlimited emails, automation, and analytics.
The price increases as the number of subscribers grows, with various tiers accommodating larger subscriber lists.
MailshakeEmail Outreach Plan: Priced at $59/user/month when billed annually. Includes features like email personalization, lead catchers, and analytics.
Sales Engagement Plan: Priced at $99/user/month when billed annually. Includes additional features like phone dialer, social selling, and Salesforce integration.
Both plans offer features tailored for sales teams and agencies focusing on cold email outreach and sales engagement.

Breaking Down the Pricing Structures

Automizy’s Subscriber-Based Pricing

Automizy follows a subscriber-based pricing model, offering a straightforward and scalable solution for businesses of various sizes. The cost is determined by the number of subscribers on the user’s email list, with different pricing tiers designed to accommodate the evolving needs of a growing business. This model is particularly advantageous for businesses that prefer a predictable cost structure that aligns with the growth of their subscriber base.

The clarity of Automizy’s pricing allows businesses to easily anticipate their monthly expenses based on their number of subscribers. While this model provides predictability, it’s crucial for businesses to closely monitor their subscriber list size, as an increase in subscribers directly impacts the overall cost, especially for businesses on a rapid growth trajectory.

Mailshake’s Feature-Focused Pricing

Mailshake takes a different approach to pricing, offering plans that are primarily based on the feature set rather than the number of subscribers or emails sent. This structure allows businesses to choose a plan based on the specific tools and capabilities they require for their outreach campaigns. Mailshake’s plans are designed to cater to the needs of businesses at different stages, from those just starting out with cold email outreach to those requiring advanced automation and integration features.

Mailshake’s pricing model emphasizes the value of features and functionality, ensuring that businesses have access to the tools they need without the constraints of subscriber counts or sending limits. However, businesses need to evaluate the features included in each plan to ensure that they align with their specific outreach strategies and goals.

Evaluating Feature Inclusion and Additional Costs

Automizy’s Comprehensive Feature Set

Automizy is renowned for its inclusive range of features across all pricing tiers, ensuring that businesses have access to essential tools like automation workflows, A/B testing, and analytics, regardless of the plan they choose. This inclusivity means that businesses can benefit from a robust set of marketing tools without needing to upgrade to more expensive plans. However, it’s important to remember that the pricing is directly linked to the subscriber count, which necessitates careful list management to control costs.

Mailshake’s Tailored Feature Packages

Mailshake offers a selection of features tailored to meet the diverse requirements of businesses, with different plans providing varying levels of access to tools such as email scheduling, automation, and integration capabilities. The focus is on providing a targeted set of tools for each pricing tier, allowing businesses to select a plan that matches their specific outreach needs. Businesses must carefully consider which features are critical to their campaigns and select a plan that provides these functionalities without incurring unnecessary costs for unneeded features.

Choosing between Automizy and Mailshake involves a detailed analysis of each platform’s pricing structure and how it correlates with a business’s specific outreach needs, budget, and growth plans. Automizy’s subscriber-based pricing model offers simplicity and scalability, ideal for businesses that want a direct link between their list size and marketing expenses. Conversely, Mailshake’s feature-focused pricing provides flexibility and customization, perfect for businesses that prioritize specific outreach tools and functionalities.

In making this decision, businesses should weigh not only the cost implications but also the overall value each platform brings in terms of features, scalability, and the potential to enhance outreach effectiveness. Whether the preference is for Automizy’s predictable pricing or Mailshake’s feature-centric approach, the chosen platform should serve as a strategic asset in driving successful email outreach campaigns and achieving substantial business growth.

WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Related: Check out our free SEO suite

Free SEO Suite by WinSavvy

Integration Capabilities: The Connective Power

Automizy: The Integration Hub

Automizy understands the importance of integrations in streamlining your marketing processes. It’s like a universal adapter that fits into your existing marketing tech stack with minimal fuss. The platform offers a wide range of integrations with popular CRM systems, e-commerce platforms, and other marketing tools.

What’s impressive about Automizy’s integrations is the ease with which they can be set up. You don’t need to be a tech wizard to connect Automizy with your favorite tools. Whether it’s syncing your CRM data to create personalized email campaigns or connecting with e-commerce platforms to automate post-purchase communication, Automizy makes it easy.

Another standout feature is Automizy’s integration with Zapier. This opens up a world of possibilities, allowing you to connect with thousands of apps. It’s like having a Swiss Army knife for your marketing campaigns, ensuring you can automate almost any aspect of your workflow.

Mailshake: Focused and Functional Integrations

Mailshake, while not offering as extensive an integration list as Automizy, focuses on integrations that add the most value to its core functionality – sales outreach. The platform integrates seamlessly with major CRM systems, allowing sales teams to keep their outreach and customer data in sync.

One of the most useful integrations for Mailshake users is LinkedIn. Given the platform’s importance in B2B sales and networking, this integration is a game-changer. It allows users to extend their email outreach efforts to social media, increasing the touchpoints with potential clients.

The integration with phone services is another boon for sales teams. This feature enables you to add calls to your outreach sequence, providing a more personalized approach than email alone.

Integration Showdown

When it comes to integrations, Automizy takes the lead if you’re looking for a tool that can integrate with a wide array of applications and enhance your overall marketing automation. Its user-friendly integration process makes it accessible even to those with minimal technical expertise.

Mailshake, on the other hand, shines in its targeted integrations that support its core purpose of sales outreach. Its LinkedIn and phone service integrations are particularly valuable for sales professionals looking to diversify their outreach strategies.

The choice here depends on your needs: Do you require a tool that offers broad integration capabilities to support a wide range of marketing activities, or are you looking for a tool that provides focused integrations to enhance your sales outreach?

Deliverability and Spam Compliance: Ensuring Your Emails Get Seen

Automizy: Deliverability with a Dash of AI

Automizy takes deliverability seriously. It’s not just about sending emails; it’s about ensuring those emails land in the inbox, not the spam folder. The platform employs advanced AI algorithms to optimize your email deliverability rates. This includes managing send times and frequencies to avoid spam filters and improve open rates.

What’s more, Automizy provides valuable insights into why certain emails may not be performing well in terms of deliverability. It could be due to content that triggers spam filters, poor sender reputation, or other factors. Automizy not only identifies these issues but also offers suggestions on how to fix them.

The platform also adheres strictly to anti-spam laws like CAN-SPAM, GDPR, and others, ensuring that your email campaigns are compliant with global regulations. This is crucial in building and maintaining trust with your audience.

Mailshake: Prioritizing Personalized Outreach

Mailshake approaches deliverability with a focus on personalized outreach. Since its core users are sales teams and professionals, the platform emphasizes sending targeted, personalized emails, which naturally have higher deliverability rates than mass, generic email blasts.

Mailshake provides users with best practices on how to avoid spam filters, including advice on email content, sender reputation, and engagement rates. It’s like having a guide that helps you navigate the tricky waters of email deliverability.

Additionally, Mailshake takes spam compliance seriously. It offers built-in features to ensure your emails are compliant with regulations, including easy-to-manage unsubscribe links and clear labeling of promotional content.

The Verdict on Deliverability and Spam Compliance

In the realm of deliverability and spam compliance, both Automizy and Mailshake offer robust solutions, but with different approaches. Automizy is ideal if you’re looking for an AI-driven approach to optimize deliverability and navigate the complexities of email regulations. Its insights into deliverability issues are particularly valuable for marketers looking to improve their email performance.

Mailshake, with its emphasis on personalized outreach, naturally aligns with high deliverability rates and is a strong choice for sales-focused users. Its compliance features and best practices guidance make it a reliable tool for sales professionals who want to maintain a clean reputation while reaching out to prospects.

Both tools ensure that your emails have the best chance of landing in the intended inboxes, but your choice will depend on whether you prioritize an AI-driven optimization approach or a personalized, sales-focused strategy.

Customer Support and Community: Your Safety Net and Success Network

Automizy: Responsive Support with a Personal Touch

Automizy really shines when it comes to customer support. They seem to understand that even the most user-friendly tool can leave users with questions and challenges. That’s where their responsive and knowledgeable support team comes into play. Whether you’re dealing with a technical glitch or need advice on best practices, their support is just a few clicks away.

But what truly sets Automizy apart is the personal touch they add to their support. Users often praise the platform for its friendly and helpful customer service, which doesn’t just solve problems but also guides and educates. This approach not only fixes immediate issues but also empowers users to become better email marketers.

Beyond direct support, Automizy also offers a wealth of resources, including webinars, detailed guides, and a blog full of insightful articles. These resources are invaluable for both beginners and seasoned email marketers looking to stay on top of the latest trends and techniques.

Mailshake: A Community-Driven Approach

Mailshake takes a slightly different approach to support, focusing heavily on community engagement. They have cultivated a robust community of sales professionals and email marketers who share tips, strategies, and success stories. This peer-to-peer learning environment can be incredibly valuable, especially for those who learn best from real-world examples and discussions.

In terms of direct customer support, Mailshake is reliable and efficient. Users have access to a dedicated support team that’s known for its quick and helpful responses. However, the real gem is the community forums and groups where users can ask questions, exchange ideas, and get feedback from both peers and the Mailshake team.

Mailshake also offers a rich library of educational content, including how-to guides, best practices, and case studies. This content is particularly geared towards sales outreach and is updated regularly to reflect the latest trends and techniques in the industry.

Customer Support and Community: Two Paths to Empowerment

Choosing between Automizy and Mailshake in terms of customer support and community depends on your preferred style of learning and interaction. If you value direct, responsive, and personalized support to guide you through your email marketing journey, Automizy is a great choice. Their hands-on approach to customer service and educational resources are top-notch.

On the other hand, if you thrive in a community-driven environment where you can learn from peers and contribute to discussions, Mailshake’s vibrant community and resource-rich platform will suit you well. The communal knowledge and experience shared among users are invaluable, especially for those in the sales field.

Both platforms excel in providing the support and resources you need to succeed in your email marketing and sales outreach efforts. The decision here hinges on whether you prefer a more personal, direct support approach or a community-driven learning experience.


In our comprehensive exploration of Automizy and Mailshake, we’ve delved into several key areas crucial for any email marketing tool: ease of use, automation and workflow capabilities, analytics and reporting, integration capabilities, deliverability and spam compliance, and customer support and community. Automizy stands out for its user-friendly interface, advanced automation capabilities powered by AI, and detailed analytics with actionable insights. Its wide range of integrations and excellent customer support make it a great choice for businesses seeking a comprehensive email marketing solution that’s easy to use yet powerful.

Mailshake, on the other hand, excels in its focused approach towards sales and outreach. Its strengths in personalized email sequences, sales-centric reporting, and integration with sales and social media tools make it ideal for sales teams and professionals. The vibrant community and peer-to-peer learning environment it offers are invaluable for those looking to learn from real-world applications. Both platforms offer unique strengths, and your decision should align with your marketing strategies and goals. Whether it’s Automizy’s AI-driven insights or Mailshake’s sales-oriented approach, both tools are poised to help you elevate your email marketing game in 2024.

Read Next:

author avatar
Poulomi Chakraborty
Poulomi Chakraborty is at the heart of our digital marketing team at WinSavvy. With a keen grasp on the ever-evolving world of SEO and digital trends, she is known for her thoughtful and strategic approach. Poulomi blends deep industry knowledge with a genuine enthusiasm for helping businesses shine online. Her ability to translate complex digital concepts into clear, actionable strategies is what sets her apart.
Scroll to Top