Mailshake vs EmailOctopus: The Best Email Marketing Tool for You

Discover the key differences between Mailshake and EmailOctopus in our detailed review to choose the best email marketing tool for you.

In the digital ocean where email marketing reigns supreme, two formidable creatures, Mailshake and EmailOctopus, glide through the waters, each offering unique powers to marketers in pursuit of engagement and conversion. Choosing between them isn’t just about selecting a tool; it’s about finding an ally that resonates with your strategy, simplifies your workflow, and amplifies your message. Whether you’re casting nets for leads or navigating the currents of customer retention, understanding the nuances of Mailshake and EmailOctopus is key. Let’s dive into their capabilities, starting with a vital aspect of any email marketing tool: Ease of Use and User Interface.

Mailshakeemail octopus
G2 Score – 4.7 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – 4.2 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score – 8.6 out of 10TrustRadius Score – Nil

Ease of Use and User Interface

The interface of an email marketing tool significantly impacts your daily operations, influencing campaign setup speed, ease of navigation, and overall user satisfaction. Here’s how Mailshake and EmailOctopus compare in providing a seamless user experience.

Mailshake: Simplifying Sales Outreach

Mailshake has carved a niche for itself with a platform celebrated for its clean, intuitive interface. Designed with the user in mind, it offers a straightforward pathway to creating and launching personalized email sequences. This simplicity ensures that marketers and sales teams can focus on crafting compelling messages without getting bogged down by complex navigation or overwhelming features. Mailshake’s dashboard is a testament to the power of user-friendly design, enabling quick access to campaign statistics, lead management, and automation workflows with just a few clicks.

EmailOctopus: Empowering Marketers with Flexibility

EmailOctopus, on the other hand, offers a blend of simplicity and flexibility, catering to a broad spectrum of email marketing needs. From creating beautiful newsletters to setting up automated email sequences, its interface combines ease of use with a range of customization options. Users can take advantage of EmailOctopus’s drag-and-drop editor and a selection of templates to design emails that captivate their audience. Despite its expansive capabilities, EmailOctopus manages to maintain a clutter-free environment, ensuring that both novice and experienced marketers can navigate the platform efficiently.

Making the Right Choice for Your Team

Deciding between Mailshake and EmailOctopus on the basis of ease of use and user interface depends on your team’s needs and the complexity of your email marketing campaigns. If your focus lies on sales outreach and you value a tool that offers a no-frills, straightforward approach to campaign creation and management, Mailshake’s streamlined interface is likely to appeal to you. Its emphasis on efficiency makes it an excellent choice for teams looking to quickly launch and iterate on their outreach strategies.

Conversely, if your marketing efforts demand a more versatile platform capable of supporting a wider range of email types, from newsletters to automated sequences, EmailOctopus’s flexible and user-friendly design offers the creative freedom to experiment with your campaigns while keeping the user experience smooth and accessible.

Ultimately, whether you choose the focused simplicity of Mailshake or the adaptable interface of EmailOctopus, ensuring that your email marketing tool enhances your workflow and fits seamlessly into your strategy is key to unlocking the full potential of your campaigns.

Integration Capabilities

The ability of an email marketing platform to integrate with CRMs, e-commerce platforms, social media, and other marketing tools can significantly enhance the efficiency and effectiveness of your marketing efforts. Here’s how Mailshake and EmailOctopus stack up in terms of integration capabilities.

Mailshake: Streamlined Sales Integrations

Mailshake focuses on providing a set of integrations that are particularly valuable for sales teams and outbound email campaigns. It offers direct integrations with popular CRMs like Salesforce and Pipedrive, making it easier for users to sync their sales activities with their email outreach efforts. Additionally, Mailshake leverages Zapier to expand its integration capabilities, connecting users to a wide array of apps and services for automating workflows, capturing leads, and managing customer data.

This approach ensures that while Mailshake might not have an extensive list of native integrations, it covers the essentials for sales-oriented activities and offers flexibility through Zapier. It’s particularly beneficial for businesses focused on leveraging email for sales outreach and lead generation, providing the necessary tools to streamline their processes.

EmailOctopus: Wide Range of Marketing Integrations

EmailOctopus presents a broader approach to integrations, catering to a more diverse set of marketing needs. Beyond email, it allows for easy connections with e-commerce platforms like Shopify and WooCommerce, enabling users to tailor their email campaigns based on customer purchase behavior and history. EmailOctopus also integrates with WordPress, offering sign-up forms that can be directly embedded into websites to capture leads.

Similar to Mailshake, EmailOctopus utilizes Zapier to further enhance its integration capabilities, granting access to hundreds of additional services and apps. This wide range of integrations supports a holistic marketing strategy, allowing businesses to seamlessly connect their email marketing efforts with their overall online presence and customer management systems.

Choosing Based on Your Integration Needs

When comparing Mailshake and EmailOctopus based on their integration capabilities, consider the tools and platforms that are most critical to your marketing and sales strategies.

If your primary goal is sales outreach and you need a tool that integrates smoothly with CRMs and enhances your sales process, Mailshake’s focused set of integrations and its flexibility through Zapier could be the ideal fit. Its sales-centric integration approach is designed to support outbound email campaigns and lead management effectively.

On the other hand, if you’re looking for a tool that supports a broader marketing strategy, integrating not just with CRMs but also with e-commerce platforms, content management systems, and more, EmailOctopus offers a wider array of native integrations plus the expansive possibilities through Zapier. This makes it well-suited for businesses aiming to create a cohesive marketing ecosystem that encompasses various tools and channels.

Ultimately, the right choice depends on the specific integration requirements of your business and how you plan to leverage your email marketing tool within your broader marketing and sales tech stack. Whether you need focused sales integrations or a broad spectrum of marketing connections, both Mailshake and EmailOctopus offer compelling solutions tailored to different needs.

Template Design and Customization

The ability to quickly create engaging, branded emails that capture the attention of your audience is a key feature of any email marketing tool. Here’s how Mailshake and EmailOctopus address this need with their template design and customization capabilities.

Mailshake: Simplified Approach for Sales-focused Emails

Mailshake takes a straightforward approach to email design, focusing on simplicity and functionality over elaborate visuals. It offers a range of basic templates geared towards sales and outreach efforts, emphasizing clear, concise messaging that drives recipients towards taking action. While Mailshake’s templates may not feature the most advanced design elements, they are customizable to a degree, allowing users to inject brand identity into their communications.

The platform’s strength lies in its ability to facilitate rapid campaign creation, enabling users to focus more on the content and personalization of their messages rather than intricate design details. This makes Mailshake particularly appealing for users who prioritize direct communication and efficiency in their email outreach campaigns.

EmailOctopus: Rich Design Options for Creative Flexibility

EmailOctopus provides users with a broader selection of templates and a more flexible editor for crafting emails. Its templates range from simple, text-focused layouts to more complex, visually driven designs, catering to a variety of campaign types, including newsletters, promotional announcements, and event invitations. The drag-and-drop editor enhances the customization process, making it easy for marketers of all skill levels to create professional-looking emails that align with their brand’s aesthetic.

Beyond template variety, EmailOctopus’s design tools allow for a higher degree of personalization and creative expression, enabling businesses to truly differentiate their emails in crowded inboxes. For users looking to leverage email marketing not just for direct sales outreach but as a comprehensive tool for engagement and brand building, EmailOctopus offers the creative freedom to bring diverse campaign ideas to life.

Selecting the Right Tool for Email Design

Choosing between Mailshake and EmailOctopus based on template design and customization capabilities boils down to your campaign goals and design needs.

If your strategy is centered around sales outreach and you prefer a tool that simplifies the email creation process with a focus on content and personalization, Mailshake’s streamlined approach to design could be more aligned with your needs. Its simplicity supports quick campaign setup and execution, ideal for users who value efficiency.

Conversely, if your campaigns require a variety of email types and you place high importance on visual appeal and brand consistency, EmailOctopus’s rich template selection and flexible design tools offer the versatility to craft engaging, visually captivating emails. Its platform caters to marketers seeking to explore the full creative potential of their email campaigns.

Ultimately, whether you choose Mailshake for its straightforward, content-focused templates or EmailOctopus for its design flexibility and variety, ensuring your chosen platform supports your marketing objectives and resonates with your brand identity is key to engaging your audience effectively through email.

WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Automation and Workflow Capabilities

Efficiently managing email campaigns often requires more than just sending out blasts to your subscriber list; it involves segmenting audiences, personalizing messages, and scheduling communications based on user behavior. Here’s how Mailshake and EmailOctopus enable these capabilities.

Mailshake: Simplified Automation for Outreach

Mailshake’s strength lies in its streamlined approach to automation, particularly designed for sales outreach and follow-up sequences. The platform allows users to easily create automated email sequences that can be triggered by specific actions, such as opening an email or clicking a link. This functionality is instrumental in keeping potential leads engaged with minimal manual effort, making it an excellent choice for sales teams looking to automate their outreach process.

While Mailshake provides essential automation features that facilitate personalized communication at scale, its capabilities are primarily tailored to sales-driven activities. This focus ensures that users can leverage automation to enhance their outreach effectiveness, though it may lack some of the advanced workflow customization options found in more comprehensive email marketing platforms.

EmailOctopus: Versatile Automation for Diverse Campaigns

EmailOctopus offers a broader set of automation features that cater to a wide range of email marketing needs beyond sales outreach. Its capabilities include not only the automation of email sequences based on subscriber actions but also the ability to segment lists dynamically, allowing for highly targeted communications. Users can craft complex workflows that automatically adapt to how subscribers interact with their emails, ensuring that each message is as relevant and timely as possible.

Furthermore, EmailOctopus’s automation tools extend to scheduling and A/B testing, giving marketers the flexibility to optimize their campaigns based on data-driven insights. This level of versatility makes EmailOctopus a strong contender for businesses that require comprehensive automation capabilities to support a variety of marketing strategies.

Choosing Based on Your Automation Needs

The decision between Mailshake and EmailOctopus in terms of automation and workflow capabilities should align with the complexity of your email marketing strategies and the specific automation features you require.

For organizations focusing on sales outreach with a need for straightforward, effective automation tools, Mailshake offers a solid solution that simplifies the creation and management of personalized email sequences. Its targeted approach to automation supports sales teams in maintaining high levels of engagement with minimal manual effort.

On the other hand, if your marketing efforts demand more versatile automation features to support diverse campaigns, including detailed segmentation, dynamic content, and advanced scheduling, EmailOctopus provides the comprehensive tools necessary to execute sophisticated, data-driven email strategies.

Ultimately, whether you opt for the streamlined efficiency of Mailshake or the extensive automation capabilities of EmailOctopus, ensuring that the platform you choose can support your marketing objectives and scale with your business is key to maximizing the impact of your email marketing efforts.

Advanced Analytics and Reporting

In today’s data-driven marketing environment, the depth and accessibility of campaign analytics play a pivotal role in shaping strategy, optimizing engagement, and understanding audience behavior. Here’s a closer look at how Mailshake and EmailOctopus provide users with the insights needed for data-driven decision-making.

Mailshake: Actionable Insights for Sales Optimization

Mailshake focuses on delivering analytics that are directly actionable, catering specifically to sales teams and marketers looking for straightforward insights into their campaigns. It provides key metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and response rates, presented in an intuitive and accessible manner. This allows users to quickly gauge the effectiveness of their outreach efforts and make necessary adjustments to improve performance.

While Mailshake’s analytics are robust enough to inform sales strategies, they are designed to be easily understood, avoiding overwhelming users with excessive data. This approach ensures that even those with limited analytical experience can draw valuable conclusions and take action to enhance their outreach effectiveness.

EmailOctopus: Comprehensive Reporting for In-depth Analysis

EmailOctopus offers a more comprehensive suite of analytics and reporting tools, designed to give marketers a detailed view of their campaigns’ performance. Beyond basic metrics, it provides insights into subscriber growth, engagement trends, and the long-term impact of specific campaigns. Advanced segmentation in reporting allows for a granular analysis of how different audience segments interact with your emails, enabling targeted strategy adjustments.

Furthermore, EmailOctopus supports A/B testing with detailed reporting on the results, helping marketers refine their email content and design for optimal engagement. This level of detail in analytics and reporting makes EmailOctopus a powerful tool for marketers who rely on in-depth data analysis to drive their email strategies.

Leveraging Data for Email Marketing Success

Choosing between Mailshake and EmailOctopus based on their analytics and reporting capabilities boils down to your specific needs for data analysis and how you intend to use those insights to inform your email marketing strategies.

If you’re looking for an analytics platform that offers clear, actionable insights tailored to optimizing sales outreach, Mailshake provides the essential metrics needed to assess and improve your campaigns quickly. Its user-friendly approach to analytics makes it ideal for teams that want to focus on action over analysis.

Conversely, if your strategy demands a deep dive into campaign data, with detailed reporting on subscriber behavior and engagement trends, EmailOctopus’s comprehensive analytics suite offers the tools for extensive evaluation and optimization. Its advanced reporting capabilities are suited for marketers who prioritize data-driven decision-making and detailed performance analysis.

Ultimately, whether you choose Mailshake for its straightforward, actionable analytics or EmailOctopus for its in-depth reporting features, ensuring that your chosen platform’s analytics capabilities align with your marketing objectives and decision-making processes is crucial for maximizing the effectiveness of your email marketing efforts.

Pricing Aspect of Mailshake and EmailOctopus

MailshakeEmail Outreach Plan: Priced at $59/user/month when billed annually. Includes features like email personalization, lead catchers, and analytics.
Sales Engagement Plan: Priced at $99/user/month when billed annually. Includes additional features like phone dialer, social selling, and Salesforce integration.
Both plans offer features tailored for sales teams and agencies focusing on cold email outreach and sales engagement.
EmailOctopusFree Plan: Offers basic features for up to 2,500 subscribers and 10,000 emails per month.
Pro Plan: Pricing starts based on the number of subscribers, beginning at $20 per month for up to 5,000 subscribers, with unlimited emails. The price increases as the number of subscribers grows.
The Pro Plan also includes more advanced features like enhanced reporting, priority support, and access to more detailed analytics.

Mailshake Pricing: Straightforward and Sales-focused

Mailshake adopts a clear, straightforward pricing model, typically offering several tiers based on features and usage limits. This model is designed to cater to businesses of various sizes, from individual users to large teams, with the cost scaling according to the level of functionality required. Pricing tiers may include basic features essential for email outreach and follow-ups, with more advanced tiers offering additional capabilities such as A/B testing, advanced scheduling, and more extensive integration options.

One of the strengths of Mailshake’s pricing is its transparency, allowing businesses to easily anticipate their expenses without worrying about hidden fees. The focus on sales and outreach means that even the entry-level plans are equipped with powerful tools designed to enhance your sales efforts, making it a cost-effective option for businesses prioritizing direct outreach.

EmailOctopus Pricing: Flexibility and Value

EmailOctopus offers a flexible pricing structure that appeals to a wide range of users, from small startups to larger enterprises. It typically includes a free tier with basic functionality, which is great for small businesses or those just starting with email marketing. Paid plans are based on the number of subscribers and emails sent, allowing businesses to choose a plan that best fits their size and email volume.

EmailOctopus’s pricing model is designed to provide value for money, offering competitive rates that include access to a suite of marketing tools, including customizable templates, automation features, and detailed analytics. The platform’s affordability combined with its comprehensive feature set makes it an attractive option for businesses looking for a balance between cost and capability.

Making an Informed Pricing Decision

Choosing between Mailshake and EmailOctopus based on pricing involves considering not only the immediate cost but also the features and value each platform offers in relation to your specific email marketing needs.

For businesses focused on sales outreach and looking for a platform with a straightforward pricing model that scales with added features, Mailshake presents an appealing option. Its clear tiered pricing ensures that you pay for the functionalities you need without unnecessary extras.

On the other hand, if you’re seeking a flexible, cost-effective solution for a broader range of email marketing activities, EmailOctopus’s pricing structure offers the advantage of starting with a free tier and scaling up as your needs grow. Its competitive pricing and comprehensive feature set provide a strong value proposition for businesses at various stages of growth.

Ultimately, whether Mailshake’s sales-oriented pricing model or EmailOctopus’s flexible, value-driven approach better suits your budget and marketing strategy, carefully evaluating each platform’s pricing against your requirements will ensure you choose the tool that offers the best return on investment for your email marketing efforts.


Choosing between Mailshake and EmailOctopus hinges on understanding your specific email marketing goals, budget constraints, and desired features. Mailshake offers a streamlined, sales-focused approach with a straightforward pricing model ideal for teams prioritizing direct outreach and efficiency. Its clear, tiered plans cater to businesses looking to optimize their sales processes with minimal fuss. EmailOctopus, on the other hand, stands out for its flexibility and value, presenting a scalable solution that begins with a generous free tier, making it suitable for a broad range of marketing activities from startups to growing enterprises.

The decision ultimately rests on whether you need a tool specifically sharpened for sales outreach or a versatile platform that grows with your marketing ambitions. Assessing each tool’s pricing structure against the backdrop of your campaign objectives will guide you to the choice that maximizes your email marketing effectiveness while aligning with your financial planning.

Read Next:

author avatar
Poulomi Chakraborty
Poulomi Chakraborty is at the heart of our digital marketing team at WinSavvy. With a keen grasp on the ever-evolving world of SEO and digital trends, she is known for her thoughtful and strategic approach. Poulomi blends deep industry knowledge with a genuine enthusiasm for helping businesses shine online. Her ability to translate complex digital concepts into clear, actionable strategies is what sets her apart.
Scroll to Top