Mailshake vs dotdigital Engagement Cloud: The Best Email Marketing Tool for You

Find out if Mailshake or dotdigital Engagement Cloud is the right email marketing tool for you with our comprehensive comparison guide.

In the digital age, where email inboxes are battlegrounds for businesses vying for attention, choosing the right email marketing tool isn’t just a decision—it’s a strategy. Enter Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud, two heavyweight contenders in the arena of email marketing. Each brings its unique strengths to the table, but which one is the best fit for your business? Whether you’re a small business owner wearing multiple hats, a marketing professional looking to streamline your campaigns, or a sales team eager to boost your conversion rates, this comparison aims to shed light on which tool will serve your needs best. Let’s break down the features, ease of use, pricing, and more, so you can make an informed decision without getting lost in the marketing jargon.

Mailshakedotdigital Engagement Cloud
Mailshakedotdigital enagagement cloud
G2 Score – 4.7 out of 5 stars
G2 Score – 4.3 out of 5 stars
TrustRadius Score – 8.6 out of 10TrustRadius Score – 7.6 out of 10

Personalization and Automation: Crafting Emails That Speak to The Reader

In today’s marketing world, personalization isn’t just a nice touch; it’s expected. The ability to tailor your messages to the individual preferences and behaviors of your subscribers can significantly impact your engagement rates and overall success. Coupled with automation, personalization can transform your email marketing from a shot in the dark to a precise, targeted strategy. Here’s how Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud stack up in these crucial areas.

Personalizing Your Approach with Mailshake

Mailshake starts strong with a focus on simplicity and effectiveness, particularly appealing to those with straightforward email outreach needs. Its personalization features allow you to insert custom fields and use conditional content, ensuring that each recipient feels like the message was crafted just for them. Where Mailshake shines is in its user-friendly approach to setting up these personalized elements, making it accessible even to those who might not be tech-savvy.

Automation in Mailshake is designed to make follow-up sequences less of a chore and more of a strategic asset. You can easily set up campaigns to send automated emails based on recipient actions, such as opens, clicks, or replies. This level of automation ensures that your follow-ups are timely and relevant, increasing the chances of converting prospects into customers.

Elevating Campaigns with dotdigital Engagement Cloud

dotdigital Engagement Cloud takes personalization and automation to a more advanced level, offering a suite of tools designed for marketers looking to create comprehensive, data-driven campaigns. Its segmentation capabilities are robust, allowing you to divide your audience based on a wide array of criteria, from demographic details to past purchase behavior and website interactions. This enables highly targeted email campaigns that speak directly to the recipient’s interests and needs.

The platform’s automation features are equally impressive, with options for creating complex journey workflows that guide subscribers through a tailored email experience based on their interactions. dotdigital’s visual journey builder allows for the creation of multi-step campaigns that can include triggers, conditions, and actions, making it possible to automate nearly every aspect of the email marketing process.

The Verdict: Matching Tools to Your Marketing Ambitions

Choosing between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud on the basis of personalization and automation comes down to your specific needs and how deep you want to dive into the customization and automation of your email campaigns.

Mailshake is ideal for those who need a straightforward, easy-to-use platform that still offers the power to personalize and automate effectively. It’s particularly suited for small businesses or individuals who prioritize ease of use and simplicity without sacrificing the ability to connect personally with their audience.

dotdigital Engagement Cloud, on the other hand, is the better choice for marketing teams looking for depth and sophistication in their email campaigns. Its advanced segmentation, detailed personalization, and comprehensive automation features make it a powerhouse for businesses ready to leverage data for highly targeted, automated marketing strategies.

In the end, the choice between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud will hinge on the complexity of your email marketing goals and the resources you have to achieve them. Whether simplicity and user-friendliness or depth and advanced capabilities are your priority, both platforms offer compelling benefits for the modern marketer.

Integration Capabilities: The Connective Tissue of Your Marketing Ecosystem

In the vast and interconnected world of digital marketing, your email marketing tool shouldn’t be an island but a hub, connected to various parts of your business. Here’s how Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud fare in knitting together the different threads of your marketing tapestry.

Mailshake: Streamlined for Simplicity

Mailshake understands that while its primary focus is email outreach, its users rely on a variety of tools to manage their workflows. To this end, Mailshake offers integrations with some of the most popular CRMs, like Salesforce and Pipedrive, ensuring that sales teams can keep their email outreach in sync with their sales processes. Additionally, through Zapier, Mailshake opens the door to hundreds of other integrations, allowing users to connect to everything from social media platforms to project management tools.

The beauty of Mailshake’s integration approach lies in its simplicity. The platform doesn’t overwhelm with countless native integrations but instead focuses on providing seamless connections to major platforms, supplemented by the versatility of Zapier. This approach ensures that users can easily link their email campaigns to their broader marketing and sales ecosystem without a steep learning curve.

dotdigital Engagement Cloud: A Wide Net of Native Integrations

In contrast, dotdigital Engagement Cloud casts a wider net with its array of native integrations. The platform boasts direct connections to a wealth of e-commerce platforms, CRM systems, social media networks, and more, reflecting its aim to serve as the central nerve system of your digital marketing strategy. For e-commerce businesses, in particular, dotdigital’s deep integration with platforms like Magento, Shopify, and BigCommerce offers a significant advantage, enabling sophisticated, data-driven email campaigns based directly on customer behavior and purchase history.

Moreover, dotdigital doesn’t stop at e-commerce and CRM integrations. It extends its connectivity to analytics tools, social media platforms, and even customer service software, ensuring that every aspect of the customer experience can be enhanced and informed by your email marketing efforts. This comprehensive approach to integration underscores dotdigital’s commitment to providing a holistic marketing solution, capable of adapting to the diverse needs of its users.

The Verdict: Choosing Your Level of Connectivity

When it comes to integration capabilities, the choice between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud hinges on the breadth of connections you need and the complexity of your marketing stack.

For those who value simplicity and are focused on sales and email outreach, Mailshake’s streamlined approach to integrations, bolstered by the power of Zapier, offers an efficient way to connect your email marketing with other key tools in your workflow. It’s an excellent choice for small to medium-sized businesses that require flexibility without the need for extensive direct integrations.

On the other hand, dotdigital Engagement Cloud is the clear winner for businesses that demand a wide range of native integrations, particularly in the e-commerce space. Its ability to natively integrate with a plethora of platforms makes it a powerful option for those looking to leverage deep data insights across their marketing, sales, and customer service efforts, providing a unified view of the customer journey.

Ultimately, your integration needs will depend on the complexity of your marketing ecosystem and where email marketing fits within it. Whether you’re looking for targeted simplicity or comprehensive connectivity, both Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud offer compelling options to keep your marketing tools in harmony.

Analytics and Reporting: Deciphering the Data

In the digital marketing realm, the power lies not just in reaching out to your audience but in understanding how they interact with your content. Here’s how both platforms stand up to the task of providing insightful analytics and reporting capabilities.

Mailshake: Focused and Actionable Insights

Mailshake keeps its analytics straightforward, focusing on delivering clear, actionable insights. The platform provides essential metrics such as open rates, click rates, response rates, and more, presented in an easy-to-understand format. This approach aligns with Mailshake’s overall emphasis on simplicity and user-friendliness, ensuring that even users with minimal marketing background can grasp their campaign performance at a glance.

Where Mailshake adds value is in how it translates these metrics into action. For example, if a particular campaign is underperforming, Mailshake offers suggestions on how to adjust your strategy, such as optimizing email subject lines or tweaking your follow-up sequence. This level of guidance is particularly beneficial for small businesses or solo marketers who need to make quick, informed decisions to improve their outreach efforts.

dotdigital Engagement Cloud: Comprehensive and Customizable Reporting

In contrast, dotdigital Engagement Cloud offers a more comprehensive suite of analytics and reporting tools designed to cater to marketers looking for depth and customization. The platform provides detailed insights into every aspect of your email campaigns, from granular engagement metrics to conversion tracking and beyond. Users can dive into the behavior of their audience, segmenting data to uncover patterns and preferences that can inform future campaigns.

One of the standout features of dotdigital’s analytics is its customizable dashboards and reports. Users can tailor their reporting interface to highlight the metrics that matter most to their business, enabling a personalized view of campaign performance. Additionally, dotdigital offers advanced reporting features like cohort analysis and comparative reporting, empowering users to conduct in-depth analyses of their marketing strategies over time.

The Verdict: Aligning Analytics with Your Needs

Choosing between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud for analytics and reporting ultimately depends on the level of detail and customization you require from your data insights.

Mailshake is well-suited for users who appreciate a straightforward, no-nonsense approach to analytics. Its focus on actionable insights makes it a great choice for smaller teams or businesses that prefer simplicity and quick adaptability in their marketing efforts.

On the other hand, dotdigital Engagement Cloud is the go-to for marketing professionals and larger businesses that crave depth in their analytics. With its customizable dashboards, comprehensive reporting, and advanced analytical tools, dotdigital provides the flexibility and insight needed to craft sophisticated, data-driven marketing strategies.

Whether your priority is ease and simplicity or detailed, customizable reporting, both Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud offer valuable analytics capabilities. Your choice should align with how much data you need to drive your marketing decisions and the complexity of the insights you wish to derive from your email campaigns.

WinSavvy helps grow VC-funded startups digitally

Related: Check out our free SEO suite

Free SEO Suite by WinSavvy

Customer Support and Learning Resources: Empowering Users for Success

Having access to timely, effective customer support and a wealth of learning resources can be a game-changer, especially when you’re looking to maximize your email marketing efforts. Here’s how Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud compare in providing support and education to their users.

Mailshake: Responsive Support With a Personal Touch

Mailshake prides itself on offering responsive and helpful customer support. Users can reach out via email or access a comprehensive FAQ section for quick answers to common questions. What sets Mailshake apart is the personal attention users receive, with support staff often going above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. This level of personalized support is especially valuable for smaller teams or those new to email marketing, as it ensures they can get the help they need without significant delays.

In addition to direct support, Mailshake offers a range of educational resources aimed at helping users improve their email outreach strategies. From detailed blog posts and guides to webinars and video tutorials, there’s a wealth of knowledge available, all designed to enhance users’ understanding of email marketing best practices and how to effectively use Mailshake to achieve their goals.

dotdigital Engagement Cloud: Comprehensive Support and Education Ecosystem

dotdigital Engagement Cloud takes a holistic approach to customer support and education, offering a wide array of resources to support its users. The platform features an extensive online knowledge base, complete with articles, how-to guides, and video tutorials covering every aspect of using the platform. For direct support, users can contact the dotdigital team via email, phone, or live chat, ensuring they can get assistance in the way that suits them best.

What truly distinguishes dotdigital is its commitment to user education and success. The platform offers training sessions, certification programs, and regular webinars that not only teach users how to use the platform but also delve into broader email marketing strategies and trends. This educational content is invaluable for businesses looking to not just execute email campaigns but to understand the why behind what works and how to continually optimize their efforts.

The Verdict: Tailoring Support to User Needs

When it comes to customer support and learning resources, both Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud excel, but they cater to slightly different user needs.

Mailshake’s approach is ideal for those who value quick, personalized support combined with a solid foundation of educational materials to help them get started and improve their email outreach efforts.

dotdigital, on the other hand, offers a more comprehensive support and education ecosystem, suited for users who seek a deep dive into not only the platform’s functionality but also advanced email marketing strategies and tactics. The availability of certification programs and in-depth training sessions makes it a great fit for businesses committed to developing their expertise in digital marketing.

Ultimately, your choice between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud should consider the level of support you anticipate needing and the importance of educational resources in enhancing your team’s email marketing skills.

Pricing: Balancing Cost and Features

MailshakeEmail Outreach Plan: Priced at $59/user/month when billed annually. Includes features like email personalization, lead catchers, and analytics.
Sales Engagement Plan: Priced at $99/user/month when billed annually. Includes additional features like phone dialer, social selling, and Salesforce integration.
Both plans offer features tailored for sales teams and agencies focusing on cold email outreach and sales engagement.
dotdigital Engagement CloudEssential Plan: Designed for small and growing businesses, includes basic email marketing features. Pricing starts at around $250/month for up to 5,000 contacts.
Business Plan: Aimed at mid-sized businesses, offers advanced features like automation, segmentation, and reporting. The pricing is custom and based on the volume of emails and contacts.
Enterprise Plan: Tailored for large organizations, includes all features in the Business plan plus additional services. Pricing is custom and based on the business requirements.

Mailshake: Accessibility and Simplicity

Mailshake offers a straightforward pricing model, designed to be accessible for businesses of all sizes. The platform typically provides a few tiers, which may include a basic plan for individuals and smaller teams focusing on simple email outreach campaigns, and more advanced plans that offer additional features like A/B testing, integrations, and advanced analytics. The pricing is usually set on a per-user basis, making it easy for businesses to scale their use of the platform as they grow.

What makes Mailshake appealing is the balance it strikes between cost and functionality. Even at its more basic level, Mailshake equips users with a robust set of tools for personalizing emails, automating sequences, and tracking campaign performance. This makes it an attractive option for startups and small businesses looking for a cost-effective way to enhance their email outreach efforts.

dotdigital Engagement Cloud: Comprehensive Solutions for a Premium

dotdigital Engagement Cloud positions itself as a premium solution, with pricing that reflects the comprehensive suite of features it offers. The platform typically provides several pricing tiers, catering to businesses with varying needs, from basic email marketing to advanced automation, segmentation, and integration capabilities. Pricing details are often tailored to each customer, taking into account factors like the number of contacts in your database, the level of customization required, and the range of features you plan to use.

The value proposition of dotdigital lies in its ability to serve as an all-in-one marketing platform, offering not just email marketing but also SMS, social media integration, and CRM capabilities. For medium to large businesses or those with sophisticated marketing needs, dotdigital offers a scalable solution that can grow with your business, providing deep insights and automation options that justify its higher price point.

The Verdict: Aligning Price with Marketing Ambitions

Choosing between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud based on pricing involves a careful consideration of your business’s size, marketing complexity, and budget.

Mailshake is well-suited for businesses seeking an effective, no-frills email marketing tool that offers great value for money. Its straightforward pricing and focus on essential features make it a smart choice for smaller businesses or those just starting with email marketing.

On the other hand, dotdigital Engagement Cloud is tailored for businesses willing to invest in a more comprehensive marketing solution that can support a wide range of strategies and channels. Its pricing reflects the advanced capabilities and scalability it offers, making it a fitting choice for larger businesses or those with more complex marketing needs.

Ultimately, the decision comes down to matching the tool not only to your current requirements but also to your future growth plans, ensuring that your investment in an email marketing platform delivers the maximum return in terms of both performance and profitability.

Campaign Creation and Execution

When it comes to email marketing, the process of campaign creation and execution is where the rubber meets the road. It’s the stage where strategies are put into action and your creative ideas begin to take shape in the form of engaging emails aimed at captivating your audience. Both Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud offer robust functionalities in this arena, but their approaches cater to different user preferences and needs.

Mailshake: Simplifying the Process

Mailshake has built its reputation on being straightforward and user-friendly, and this extends to its campaign creation and execution capabilities. The platform is designed with simplicity in mind, enabling users, regardless of their technical proficiency, to set up and launch email campaigns quickly. This ease of use is a significant advantage for small businesses or individuals who may not have a dedicated marketing team but still wish to engage in effective email outreach.

Creating a campaign in Mailshake involves a few simple steps: importing contacts, drafting your email using personalization tokens to add a custom touch, and setting up any follow-up emails. The interface guides you through each step with clear instructions, making the process intuitive. Mailshake’s strength lies in its ability to make personalized, automated email sequences accessible to everyone, allowing users to focus more on crafting compelling content and less on navigating the tool.

dotdigital Engagement Cloud: Embracing Complexity for Creativity

On the other end of the spectrum, dotdigital Engagement Cloud offers a more sophisticated approach to campaign creation and execution. It caters to marketers who seek not only to send emails but to create intricate, multi-channel marketing journeys. The platform’s visual campaign builder is a testament to its capabilities, allowing for the design of complex customer journeys that can include emails, SMS messages, social media interactions, and more.

This level of sophistication doesn’t come without its complexities. Users are encouraged to think in terms of “marketing automation” rather than just “email campaigns,” which means considering how different triggers, behaviors, and conditions can influence the path of a customer journey. For example, a campaign could start with an email, follow up with an SMS message if the email is unopened, and then tag the customer for segmentation based on their interaction. dotdigital’s platform is built to handle this complexity, offering a wide range of customization options that allow marketers to fine-tune their campaigns down to the smallest detail.

The trade-off with dotdigital’s comprehensive approach is the steeper learning curve and the increased time investment needed to fully leverage the platform’s capabilities. However, for businesses that demand this level of detail and control over their marketing campaigns, the investment can lead to highly personalized and engaging customer experiences that drive conversions and loyalty.

Choosing the Right Path

In the realm of campaign creation and execution, the choice between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud hinges on your marketing strategy’s complexity and your team’s capacity to manage these tools. Mailshake offers a streamlined, no-fuss approach that gets your campaigns off the ground quickly and efficiently, making it ideal for straightforward email outreach efforts. In contrast, dotdigital provides a powerful engine for crafting detailed, multi-touchpoint customer journeys, suited for businesses ready to dive deep into automation and personalization across multiple channels.

The decision ultimately rests on what you aim to achieve with your email marketing efforts and how much time and resources you’re willing to dedicate to mastering these platforms. Whether you value simplicity and speed or depth and customization, both Mailshake and dotdigital offer pathways to engaging your audience and achieving your marketing goals.


Choosing between Mailshake and dotdigital Engagement Cloud involves considering your business’s specific needs, marketing strategies, and the level of sophistication required. Mailshake offers an accessible, straightforward solution ideal for businesses focused on sales engagement and email outreach with a preference for simplicity and ease of use. dotdigital Engagement Cloud, on the other hand, provides a comprehensive, feature-rich platform designed for businesses seeking advanced capabilities, particularly in e-commerce and multi-channel marketing, with a willingness to invest in a more complex setup for the sake of depth and customization.

Your decision should align with your marketing objectives, the complexity of your customer engagement strategies, and how you plan to grow and scale your efforts in the future. Whether you prioritize ease of use and simplicity or require advanced features and integrations, both platforms offer distinct advantages to meet diverse email marketing needs.

Read Next:

author avatar
Poulomi Chakraborty
Poulomi Chakraborty is at the heart of our digital marketing team at WinSavvy. With a keen grasp on the ever-evolving world of SEO and digital trends, she is known for her thoughtful and strategic approach. Poulomi blends deep industry knowledge with a genuine enthusiasm for helping businesses shine online. Her ability to translate complex digital concepts into clear, actionable strategies is what sets her apart.
Scroll to Top